Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Meta Platforms sued OnlineNIC for cybersquatting and obtained a default judgment. Leascend Technology, formerly Xiamen 35.com Internet Technology, appealed the district court's determination that it was OnlineNIC's alter ego and therefore subject to personal jurisdiction in the Northern District of California. Leascend also challenged terminating sanctions, an asset freeze, and an award of costs and fees.
The Ninth Circuit panel reviewed the alter-ego determination de novo to decide whether a genuine issue of material fact existed. Under California law, alter-ego liability applies when organizations act as a single business enterprise, with outcomes turning on equitable principles and the circumstances of each case.
The district court had appointed a Special Master to investigate Leascend's discovery conduct. The Special Master found that Leascend and OnlineNIC failed to preserve potentially relevant electronically stored information before litigation, after the complaint, during discovery, and even after the Special Master's appointment, and that the defendants' behavior was intentional.
The Court’s Holding
The panel affirmed, finding no genuine factual dispute that Leascend was OnlineNIC's alter ego. The businesses shared ownership and management structures, shared almost all of OnlineNIC's employees, commingled assets, and Leascend aided concealment of the responsible ownership and financial interest by vigorously defending OnlineNIC's misconduct during discovery. Leascend offered only conclusory statements without specific material facts showing a triable dispute.
Because the alter-ego finding stood, the district court properly exercised personal jurisdiction over Leascend. Specific jurisdiction was proper because Leascend purposefully directed activities to the Northern District through OnlineNIC; the panel declined to address general jurisdiction. Terminating sanctions and default did not violate due process because the evidence showed willfulness, bad faith, and fault in failing to preserve, concealing, and actively spoliating evidence that significantly hampered Meta's ability to litigate. The asset freeze and fee award were not an abuse of discretion, and the litigation misconduct made this an exceptional case permitting reasonable attorney fees under the Lanham Act.
Concurrently with the amended memorandum disposition, the panel granted Leascend's petition for panel rehearing in part to file the amended disposition, while denying rehearing en banc and otherwise denying panel rehearing.
Key Takeaways
- Alter-ego liability can supply personal jurisdiction over a foreign company when shared ownership, employees, assets, and discovery conduct show a single business enterprise with a forum-connected affiliate.
- Intentional failure to preserve electronically stored information across all phases of litigation can justify terminating sanctions and default without offending due process.
- A district court may freeze assets and award attorney fees where a party's obfuscation and noncompliance with court orders create an exceptional Lanham Act case.
Why It Matters
This amended memorandum illustrates how discovery misconduct can independently sustain severe terminating sanctions while also reinforcing the factual basis for alter-ego findings and jurisdictional reach over related entities.
The panel's reliance on specific jurisdiction through the alter ego rather than general jurisdiction demonstrates a targeted application of forum contacts while affirming substantial equitable and monetary remedies for bad-faith litigation conduct.