Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Nurmukhamed Nurlanov filed a 28 U.S.C. § 2241 habeas corpus petition in the Central District of California challenging aspects of his immigration custody. His petition contested a November 24, 2025 custody hearing, discretionary determinations by an Immigration Judge, his May 21, 2025 arrest, the termination of his prior release, his prior treatment under mandatory detention, and the due process implications of his continued detention.
A magistrate judge issued a Report and Recommendation advising that the petition be dismissed on exhaustion grounds after reviewing the petition, respondents' response and supplemental answer, and Nurlanov's traverse and supplemental reply. Nurlanov filed objections, asserting that the magistrate judge failed to engage meaningfully with the prudential exhaustion framework under Puga v. Chertoff and claiming he had not been granted an objection period.
The district court rejected the threshold procedural objection, noting that the magistrate judge had set an objection deadline of October 8, 2026. Because Nurlanov filed his objections on October 6, 2026, the court found them timely and properly before it.
The Court’s Holding
Overruling the objections, the district court held that Nurlanov merely reiterated arguments from his petition and traverse regarding why exhaustion should not be required or should be waived. Citing Cowart v. Cardenas, the court affirmed that simply repeating prior arguments does not constitute a proper objection to a magistrate judge's report. The court observed that the magistrate judge had quoted and applied the Puga factors, correctly determining that each factor favored exhaustion and no exception applied.
The court adopted the report and issued differentiated rulings across the petition's claims. It dismissed without prejudice Nurlanov's challenge to the November 24, 2025 custody hearing for failure to exhaust administrative remedies and dismissed without prejudice his request to reweigh the Immigration Judge's discretionary determinations for lack of jurisdiction. The court denied his challenges to his May 21, 2025 arrest, the termination of his release, and prior mandatory detention treatment, including requests for immediate release and an anti-redetention injunction. Finally, it denied without prejudice his claim that continued detention violated due process, directing entry of judgment.
Key Takeaways
- Merely repeating arguments previously raised in a habeas petition and traverse does not constitute a valid objection to a magistrate judge's report and recommendation.
- Under Puga v. Chertoff, an immigration habeas challenge to a custody hearing is subject to dismissal without prejudice where prudential exhaustion factors favor administrative review and no exception applies.
- District courts lack habeas jurisdiction to reweigh discretionary immigration custody decisions made by an Immigration Judge.
- A single immigration habeas order may dismiss unexhausted or jurisdictional claims without prejudice while denying challenges to prior arrest and release decisions on the merits.
Why It Matters
The decision illustrates the rigorous enforcement of administrative exhaustion in immigration habeas litigation within the Central District of California, demonstrating that petitioners cannot bypass agency review or lodge procedurally defective objections that merely recycle earlier arguments.
It also provides a clear model for tailoring habeas dispositions to specific claims, cleanly separating unexhausted custody hearings, unreviewable discretionary calls, completed enforcement actions, and ongoing due process detention claims.