California Case Summaries

Constitutional Law

Secondary practice area

3rd District Court of Appeal, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law, Litigation

In re Sanchez — Second degree murder based on a fatal fentanyl sale can qualify as a felony involving acts of violence for bail denial, but the detention orders must be vacated because required findings were never made

The court held that the second degree murder charge was a qualifying felony because the fentanyl's deadly physical force on the victim was an act of violence closely related to the charged offense, while vacating the detention orders because the trial court never made the findings required by section 12(b).

2nd District Court of Appeal, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law

People v. Guzman — Social Media Search Warrant Upheld Under Good-Faith Exception in Retaliatory Gang Murder Conviction

The Court of Appeal affirmed Jesus Octavio Guzman's convictions for second-degree murder and premeditated attempted murder, holding that evidence obtained from a warrant search of his Instagram account was admissible under the good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule because an officer reasonably could rely on informant tips and expert gang inferences connecting him and his account to the retaliatory shooting.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Litigation

Dickinson v. Trump — Ninth Circuit Vacates Preliminary Injunction Restricting Federal Crowd-Control Munitions and Mandating Uniform Redesigns at Portland ICE Facility

The Ninth Circuit vacated a preliminary injunction and provisional class certification that restricted federal agents' deployment of non-lethal crowd-control munitions and ordered uniform redesigns outside a Portland immigration facility, holding plaintiffs failed to establish any Winter factor, demonstrate retaliatory intent, or satisfy Rule 23 commonality and indivisible-remedy requirements.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Litigation

Reach Community Development v. United States Department of Homeland Security — Substantive Due Process Does Not Protect Neighboring Residents From Incidental Exposure to Non-Lethal Crowd-Control Munitions Deployed Against Protesters

The Ninth Circuit vacated a preliminary injunction barring federal agencies from using tear gas outside a Portland ICE facility, holding that neighboring apartment residents lack a substantive due process right rooted in history and tradition to be free from chemical exposure during crowd-control operations.

3rd District Court of Appeal, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Litigation

J.O. v. Superior Court of San Joaquin County — California Court of Appeal Directs Trial Court Hearing on Remand to Review Alleged Bad-Faith Blanket Judicial Disqualification Under Section 170.6

On remand from the California Supreme Court, the Third District Court of Appeal held that a conservatee's challenge to an alleged bad-faith blanket disqualification campaign against a superior court judge was not moot and issued a peremptory writ of mandate directing the trial court to vacate its disqualification order and conduct an evidentiary hearing under the Supreme Court's three-step framework.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law, Litigation

United States v. Abdul Kareem — Ninth Circuit Reverses ISIS Material-Support Conspiracy Conviction for Insufficient Evidence of Direction or Control

The Ninth Circuit reversed Abdul Malik Abdul Kareem's conviction for conspiring to provide material support to ISIS, holding that evidence of ideological sympathy and independent violence inspired by a terrorist group's propaganda cannot sustain a conviction under 18 U.S.C. § 2339B without proof of an intent to act under the organization's direction or control.

1st District Court of Appeal, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law

People v. Fuller — Prosecution Must Prove Parole Status at Revocation Hearing Even Without Prior Objection

The First District Court of Appeal reversed a parole revocation order because the prosecution presented no evidence that Kenneth Adrian Fuller was actually on parole when the alleged violation occurred, holding that parole status must be proven even if the defendant never raises the issue before the hearing.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Litigation

Lindsay Hecox v. Madison Kenyon — Ninth Circuit Vacates Preliminary Injunction and Remands for Dismissal as Moot After Supreme Court Reversal

The Ninth Circuit vacated a preliminary injunction against Idaho's Fairness in Women's Sports Act and remanded to the district court to dismiss the case as moot because the plaintiff was no longer enrolled at Boise State and offered only a conclusory statement of intent to re-enroll without concrete steps to effectuate re-enrollment.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Election Law

Service Employees International Union v. Department of Justice — Ninth Circuit Reinstates Stay of Order Barring Federal Ballot-Sequestration Demands and Prosecution Threats

On Election Day 2026, a majority of the Ninth Circuit en banc court reinstated a panel order staying a district court's temporary restraining order that had barred federal officials from demanding ballot sequestration and threatening election officials with prosecution.

6th District Court of Appeal, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law

People v. Jimenez — Racial Justice Act Charging Claim Fails Without a Like-for-Like Comparison of Similarly Situated Murder Defendants

The Sixth District held in a partially published opinion that Racial Justice Act statistics comparing Latinx overrepresentation among life-without-parole prisoners with the general population, rather than with similarly situated murder defendants, did not make a prima facie showing of disparate special-circumstance charging.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Election Law

Service Employees International Union v. DOJ — Ninth Circuit Stays Order Barring Federal Ballot-Sequestration Requests and Prosecution Warnings

A divided Ninth Circuit panel granted the Government's motion for a stay pending appeal of a temporary restraining order that barred federal ballot-sequestration requests and prosecution warnings to election officials, concluding that the Government is likely to prevail on the Voting Rights Act and Elections Clause claims.

4th District Court of Appeal, Administrative Law, Constitutional Law, Litigation

TC Telephone v. Public Utilities Commission of the State of California — Court Modifies Opinion to Annul Per-Minute Reimbursement Findings, Holding Pre-Resolution Rules Too Vague to Support Punishment

By order filed October 27, 2026, the Court of Appeal modified its September 28, 2026 opinion to annul the portions of two Public Utilities Commission decisions finding that TC Telephone improperly sought per-minute reimbursement, holding the pre-resolution rules failed to give fair notice, while leaving all other portions of the decisions valid and remanding for recalculation.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Election Law

United States v. California — Ninth Circuit Dismisses Premature Ballot-Segregation Appeal

A divided Ninth Circuit panel dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction and denied the emergency motion as moot. Ordinarily, an appellate court reviews an order granting or denying an injunction, not a request the trial court is still actively considering. The narrow constructive-denial doctrine can treat inaction as appealable when delay effectively refuses urgently needed relief and creates imminent, severe, irreparable consequences. Those conditions were not met here.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Administrative Law, Constitutional Law, Litigation

Prado v. City of Berkeley — Ninth Circuit Partly Stays Encampment Injunction During Disease Abatement

The panel granted a stay to the extent the district court’s orders prevented Berkeley from clearing and abating the Harrison encampment. Public-health evidence showed that leaving tents and vehicles in place could shelter rats and interfere with eradication measures. That created a serious risk to residents, workers, and the public, and justified allowing the city to complete work at that location while appellate review continued.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Administrative Law, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law

Newsom v. Trump — Ninth Circuit Denies Voluntary Dismissal of Fully Briefed Appeal to Prevent Strategic Manipulation of Precedent, but Grants Dismissal of Unbriefed Extension Appeal

The Ninth Circuit denied Defendants' motion to voluntarily dismiss the fully briefed appeal of the initial federalization injunction, finding the appeal not moot and that dismissal would allow strategic manipulation of precedent, while granting dismissal of the unbriefed extension appeal.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Administrative Law, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law

Newsom v. Trump — Ninth Circuit affirms order blocking federalization and deployment of California National Guard in Los Angeles

The Ninth Circuit affirmed a district court order, reviewable as a preliminary injunction, that bars deployment of the federalized California National Guard in Los Angeles because neither 10 U.S.C. § 12406(3) nor § 12406(2) likely authorized the President's June 2025 federalization order.

2nd District Court of Appeal, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law

People v. Thomas — Investigatory Car Search Could Not Be Justified as an Inventory

The Second District reversed and ordered suppression. An inventory search must be tied to a legitimate caretaking purpose, such as protecting property, protecting police from claims, or removing a vehicle that threatens traffic or public safety. It cannot be used as a substitute for probable cause when officers hope to find evidence. The prosecution bears the burden of proving the exception.

5th District Court of Appeal, Constitutional Law, Construction Law, Litigation

Davis v. Fresno Unified School District — Bond-Funded Lease-Leaseback Violated Bidding Laws, but Contractor Need Only Return $236,129 Net Profit

The Fifth District held that a bond-funded school lease-leaseback did not qualify for the Education Code section 17406 bidding exception, rejected the Government Code section 1090 conflict claim, and directed a modified judgment requiring the contractor to return $236,129 in net profit.

Scroll to Top