Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Angel Jorge Padron, a Cuban citizen ordered removed to Cuba in 2005, had previously been detained and then released under an Order of Supervision. On February 24, 2026, Respondents revoked that release and re-detained him, citing violations of release conditions based on convictions for possession of a controlled substance, burglary, and assault, and stating an intent to remove him to Mexico.
Petitioner filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus while detained. He refused to cooperate with removal to Mexico despite increasing pressure by Respondents, raising the question whether his prolonged post-revocation detention remained constitutional when removal was not reasonably foreseeable.
The Court’s Holding
The Court agreed with Respondents that they lawfully revoked Petitioner's prior release under an Order of Supervision upon violation of conditions. However, the Court rejected Respondents' argument that continued detention remained constitutional under Zadvydas v. Davis on the theory that removal was foreseeable or that Petitioner's non-cooperation extended the removal period.
Because Petitioner had been detained under a final removal order for well over eight months and did not consent to removal to Mexico, the Court found the matter materially indistinguishable from its prior decisions in Garcia and Prado involving Cuban nationals detained under 8 U.S.C. § 1231 for more than six months to effectuate removal to Mexico over their non-consent. Resolving the case on the same basis, the Court concluded that Petitioner's removal is not reasonably foreseeable.
The Court granted the petition as to Ground One and ordered Respondents to immediately release Petitioner from custody without imposing additional restrictions beyond those in place prior to his current detention, absent a future determination at a pre-deprivation or custody hearing. The Court further enjoined Respondents from re-arresting or re-detaining him without a change in circumstances, directed service on the detention facility, and ordered the case closed with judgment entered for Petitioner.
Key Takeaways
- Lawful revocation of release under an Order of Supervision does not permit indefinite post-order detention when removal is no longer reasonably foreseeable.
- A detainee's refusal to consent to removal to a third country does not extend the removal period under Zadvydas where removal to that country is not reasonably foreseeable.
- Detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1231 exceeding eight months to effectuate non-consensual removal of a Cuban national to Mexico violates Zadvydas reasonableness standards.
- The Court granted immediate release and enjoined re-detention absent changed circumstances, while declining to reach remaining petition grounds in the interest of judicial economy.
Why It Matters
This decision reaffirms the constitutional ceiling on post-removal-order immigration detention established in Zadvydas v. Davis, applying it directly to third-country removal efforts. Even where release revocation is substantively lawful due to criminal convictions, detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1231 cannot be maintained beyond six months when the detainee refuses third-country removal and removal is not reasonably foreseeable.
By following its established precedents in Garcia and Prado, the Court reinforces uniform Eastern District of California standards governing Cuban detainees facing attempted removal to Mexico, providing prospective injunctive relief against re-arrest absent changed circumstances.