California Case Summaries

Author: automatic

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law, Litigation

United States v. Abdul Kareem — Ninth Circuit Reverses ISIS Material-Support Conspiracy Conviction for Insufficient Evidence of Direction or Control

The Ninth Circuit reversed Abdul Malik Abdul Kareem's conviction for conspiring to provide material support to ISIS, holding that evidence of ideological sympathy and independent violence inspired by a terrorist group's propaganda cannot sustain a conviction under 18 U.S.C. § 2339B without proof of an intent to act under the organization's direction or control.

1st District Court of Appeal, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law

People v. Fuller — Prosecution Must Prove Parole Status at Revocation Hearing Even Without Prior Objection

The First District Court of Appeal reversed a parole revocation order because the prosecution presented no evidence that Kenneth Adrian Fuller was actually on parole when the alleged violation occurred, holding that parole status must be proven even if the defendant never raises the issue before the hearing.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Litigation

Lindsay Hecox v. Madison Kenyon — Ninth Circuit Vacates Preliminary Injunction and Remands for Dismissal as Moot After Supreme Court Reversal

The Ninth Circuit vacated a preliminary injunction against Idaho's Fairness in Women's Sports Act and remanded to the district court to dismiss the case as moot because the plaintiff was no longer enrolled at Boise State and offered only a conclusory statement of intent to re-enroll without concrete steps to effectuate re-enrollment.

2nd District Court of Appeal, Civil Procedure, Litigation, Personal Injury & Tort

Social Media Cases (San Diego Unified School District v. Meta Platforms, Inc.) — School districts cannot pursue negligence or public nuisance claims for platform-related student harms

California's Second District Court of Appeal affirmed dismissal of four school districts' coordinated negligence and public nuisance claims against social media companies, applying the law of four states and Section 230 immunity for third-party challenge videos.

1st District Court of Appeal, Business Transactions, Civil Procedure, Litigation

Bogguess v. Uber Technologies, Inc. — Court affirms denial of arbitration because deceptive-pricing injunction is public relief and ambiguous severance language is construed against Uber

The Court of Appeal affirmed the denial of Uber's motion to compel arbitration, holding that the requested injunction against allegedly deceptive pricing is public injunctive relief and that ambiguous severance language must be construed against Uber under California contract law without FAA preemption.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Banking & Finance, Collections & Creditor Rights, Litigation

Srinivasan v. Milestone Financial, LLC — Chapter 13 debtors had an absolute right to voluntary dismissal under § 1307(b), but the one-year refiling bar imposed under § 105(a) and authorized by § 349(a) was affirmed

The Ninth Circuit reversed a bankruptcy court's dismissal of Chapter 13 cases for failure to comply with an order because the debtors had an absolute statutory right to voluntary dismissal under § 1307(b), but affirmed the one-year refiling bars that the bankruptcy court imposed for cause under § 105(a) as authorized by § 349(a).

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Election Law

Service Employees International Union v. Department of Justice — Ninth Circuit Reinstates Stay of Order Barring Federal Ballot-Sequestration Demands and Prosecution Threats

On Election Day 2026, a majority of the Ninth Circuit en banc court reinstated a panel order staying a district court's temporary restraining order that had barred federal officials from demanding ballot sequestration and threatening election officials with prosecution.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Administrative Law, Civil Procedure, Immigration

National TPS Alliance v. Mullin — Ninth Circuit denies Government’s bid to stay preliminary injunction pending appeal

After the Supreme Court vacated its earlier decision and remanded in light of Mullin v. Doe, the Ninth Circuit denied the Government's motion to stay the preliminary injunction pending appeal, denied its alternative request for an administrative stay of at least 21 days, and said it would set expedited merits briefing by separate order.

6th District Court of Appeal, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law

People v. Jimenez — Racial Justice Act Charging Claim Fails Without a Like-for-Like Comparison of Similarly Situated Murder Defendants

The Sixth District held in a partially published opinion that Racial Justice Act statistics comparing Latinx overrepresentation among life-without-parole prisoners with the general population, rather than with similarly situated murder defendants, did not make a prima facie showing of disparate special-circumstance charging.

1st District Court of Appeal, Criminal Law

People v. Savoy — Gun-enhancement racial impact must meet the Racial Justice Act’s two-part disparity test to earn great weight at resentencing

The Court of Appeal affirmed a 77-years-to-life resentence, holding that the mitigating circumstance in Penal Code section 1385(c)(2)(A) requires the same showing needed to prove a disparate-sentencing violation under the Racial Justice Act, and that statewide statistics without individual comparators did not meet it.

4th District Court of Appeal, Family Law, Litigation

Timothy S. v. Sarah H. — Grandparent visitation petition is not a Uniform Parentage Act proceeding, so no fee award under Family Code section 7605

The Court of Appeal affirmed the denial of a mother's request for attorney's fees against a grandfather seeking visitation, holding that Family Code section 7605 applies only to Uniform Parentage Act proceedings and that juvenile dependency exit orders are not UPA judgments.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, Election Law

Service Employees International Union v. DOJ — Ninth Circuit Stays Order Barring Federal Ballot-Sequestration Requests and Prosecution Warnings

A divided Ninth Circuit panel granted the Government's motion for a stay pending appeal of a temporary restraining order that barred federal ballot-sequestration requests and prosecution warnings to election officials, concluding that the Government is likely to prevail on the Voting Rights Act and Elections Clause claims.

Scroll to Top