Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Jaswinder Singh, formerly a federal immigration detainee, initiated this action by filing a petition for writ of habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2241. Following briefing by the parties, the district court on July 28, 2026, granted the petition and ordered Respondents to release Petitioner immediately, concluding that Petitioner possessed a protected liberty interest and that due process required a pre-deprivation hearing before re-detention. Final judgment in favor of Petitioner was entered thereafter.
Counsel for Petitioner subsequently moved for an award of attorney's fees and costs under the Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA), 28 U.S.C. § 2412. Respondents opposed the motion, urging the court to hold the fee proceedings in abeyance pending the Supreme Court's decision in Montoya Palacios v. Liggins. In the alternative, Respondents argued that habeas corpus proceedings are not civil actions under the EAJA, that the government's detention and litigation positions were substantially justified, and that any fee award should be substantially reduced for excessive billing.
The Court’s Holding
The magistrate judge recommended denying Respondents' request to hold the fee motion in abeyance. Applying the Landis stay factors, the magistrate judge concluded that Respondents failed to demonstrate any hardship or inequity in proceeding, while staying resolution could prejudice Petitioner's continued access to counsel. Although the Supreme Court's forthcoming decision in Palacios could inform the legal analysis, considerations of judicial economy alone do not justify an indefinite stay, warranting the exercise of discretion to resolve the pending motion.
On the statutory merits, the magistrate judge concluded that the EAJA's authorization of fee awards in any civil action unambiguously encompasses habeas petitions challenging civil immigration detention, adhering to established circuit precedent and the Supreme Court's recognition that habeas proceedings are technically civil. The magistrate judge further found that the government failed to establish substantial justification for its position. Immigration authorities paroled Petitioner into the country, where he complied with release conditions for over four years, yet re-detained him without a pre-deprivation hearing under a mandatory detention theory that ignored well-settled constitutional due process limitations.
Finally, the magistrate judge recommended granting the fee motion in part with substantial reductions. The recommendation rejected counsel's requested $400 enhanced hourly rate because counsel offered no evidence that representation was unavailable at the statutory rate, applying instead the Ninth Circuit statutory maximum of $258.46. The magistrate judge also cut five hours for excessive one-hour minimum billing for tasks taking less than a minute, and reduced the remaining hours by forty percent to account for block billing that combined legal work with non-compensable clerical tasks, recommending a total fee award of $3,359.98 plus the $5.00 filing fee, for a total of $3,364.98.
Key Takeaways
- The magistrate judge issued findings and recommendations under 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1) recommending that Petitioner's motion for attorney's fees under the Equal Access to Justice Act be granted in part in the amount of $3,364.98, subject to review and final order by the district judge.
- Immigration habeas proceedings qualify as civil actions under the EAJA, making prevailing petitioners eligible for attorney's fees and costs against the United States.
- A request to stay fee proceedings pending Supreme Court resolution of an unsettled legal issue requires the moving party to demonstrate concrete hardship or inequity, which judicial economy concerns alone cannot satisfy when delay risks harming access to counsel.
- The government's detention position is not substantially justified when it re-detains an immigrant who had been paroled and complied with release conditions for years without providing a constitutionally required pre-deprivation hearing.
- Fee applicants must justify hourly rates exceeding the statutory cap and avoid block billing or full-hour increments for brief administrative tasks, which warrant substantial percentage reductions under the lodestar calculation.
Why It Matters
This decision adds to the prevailing weight of authority within the Ninth Circuit treating immigration habeas corpus proceedings as civil actions governed by the EAJA, rejecting efforts by the government to freeze fee adjudications while awaiting Supreme Court guidance in Montoya Palacios v. Liggins.
The ruling also provides practical guidance on EAJA fee scrutiny, demonstrating that courts will rigorously enforce the statutory hourly rate cap absent concrete proof of specialized unavailability, and will apply substantial across-the-board percentage reductions when attorneys use block billing or inflate minor tasks into one-hour increments.