Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Gabriel Aaron Savage, a state prisoner proceeding without counsel, brought a civil rights action under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against California Health Care Facility officers Sergeant Joshua Brenner, Building Officer Cruz, Building Officer Anzar, and Yard Officer Cervantes. The action proceeded on an Eighth Amendment excessive-force claim against all four defendants and a separate Eighth Amendment verbal-harassment claim against Anzar. Defendants moved under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) to dismiss only the verbal-harassment claim against Anzar.
In the verbal-harassment claim, plaintiff alleged that Anzar came to his cell door on November 2, 2025, used foul language including calling him a derogatory name, threatened him, walked away when asked to leave, and returned moments later saying he was just checking on plaintiff. Plaintiff further alleged that Anzar harassed him every time Anzar visited the unit, causing depression, suicidal thoughts, paranoia, and sleep loss, and that plaintiff filed two grievances and a Prison Rape Elimination Act complaint after Anzar allegedly threatened on another occasion to assault and rape him. In opposing dismissal, plaintiff argued that his complaint stated a claim under California's Tom Bane Civil Rights Act rather than directly addressing defendants' Eighth Amendment arguments.
The magistrate judge first rejected defendants' reply argument that plaintiff's opposition was untimely. Applying the three-day mail extension under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 6(d) to an earlier thirty-day extension and giving plaintiff the benefit of the prison mailbox rule, the court found the opposition timely filed one day before the September 9, 2026 deadline.
The Court’s Holding
On the merits, the court held that the complaint failed to state a cognizable Eighth Amendment verbal-harassment claim against Anzar. Under Ninth Circuit precedent, verbal harassment violates the Eighth Amendment only if it is calculated to cause psychological damage, involves comments unusually gross even for a prison setting, and actually causes psychological harm. Plaintiff's general allegation of harassment on November 2, 2025 lacked factual detail describing the statements, and calling plaintiff a derogatory name, while offensive, was not unusually gross in a prison environment. Similarly, Anzar's alleged threat to assault and rape plaintiff did not state a constitutional violation because threats of bodily harm alone are insufficient and Eighth Amendment sexual-harassment protections do not extend to verbal abuse without physical contact.
Because plaintiff failed to plead a constitutional violation, the court declined to reach Anzar's qualified-immunity defense. However, the court granted plaintiff thirty days to file a standalone amended complaint under Local Rule 220, concluding that his allegations of persistent harassment causing severe psychological distress could potentially support an Eighth Amendment claim if he specifically describes the statements, when and where they occurred, and their duration. The court also concluded that the complaint neither pleaded nor stated a colorable Bane Act claim under California Civil Code section 52.1 because plaintiff did not connect Anzar's alleged threats to any interference with a constitutional or statutory right, though it allowed plaintiff to attempt to cure that defect on amendment and vacated a prior stay of responsive pleadings.
Key Takeaways
- Verbal harassment by prison officials violates the Eighth Amendment only when the remarks are unusually gross for a prison setting, are calculated to inflict psychological damage, and actually cause such injury.
- Isolated derogatory insults and verbal threats of physical or sexual assault, without physical contact or comparably egregious conduct, do not establish an Eighth Amendment violation under Ninth Circuit precedent.
- A claim under California's Tom Bane Civil Rights Act requires pairing threats, intimidation, or coercion with intentional interference or attempted interference with a specific constitutional or statutory right.
- Allegations of ongoing, targeted verbal abuse accompanied by concrete psychological harm such as depression, paranoia, suicidal thoughts, and sleep loss warrant leave to amend so a pro se prisoner can plead the specific statements, timing, and duration.
Why It Matters
The decision illustrates the strict pleading threshold governing prisoner verbal-harassment claims in the Ninth Circuit while recognizing that a sustained campaign of targeted psychological abuse may remain actionable if pleaded with concrete factual detail regarding the content, frequency, and duration of the remarks.
The ruling also underscores that pro se litigants cannot salvage a deficient federal harassment claim merely by invoking California's Bane Act in an opposition brief unless the underlying allegations link the alleged threats to interference with an identified legal right.