Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Trung Nguyen, a lawful permanent resident admitted as a refugee infant in 1990, was transferred to ICE custody on May 11, 2026 upon completing a sentence for misdemeanor domestic battery. That same day, ICE issued a Notice to Appear charging him as removable based on a 2022 felon-in-possession-of-ammunition conviction. An immigration judge ordered removal on July 28, 2026, but his appeal remained pending before the Board of Immigration Appeals when the court ruled.
An earlier habeas petition was dismissed without prejudice for failure to seek a Matter of Joseph custody hearing. In this action, Nguyen submitted evidence that he mailed such a request to the immigration court, ICE counsel, and the Federal Public Defender on July 20, 2026, yet the record showed no resulting custody hearing. The court therefore declined to decide exhaustion and reached his sole Fifth Amendment prolonged-detention claim.
The Court’s Holding
Assuming without deciding that detention was authorized by 8 U.S.C. § 1226(c), the court held that unreasonably prolonged mandatory detention without a bond hearing can violate due process. Applying Mathews v. Eldridge, it found Nguyen's liberty interest weighty, the risk of erroneous deprivation high because no neutral decisionmaker had assessed flight risk or danger, and the government's interest in avoiding a routine hearing low.
The court recommended granting the petition and ordering a bond hearing within fourteen days after adoption of the recommendations. At that hearing, respondents would bear the burden by clear and convincing evidence to justify continued detention, with seven days' notice, counsel participation if available, and a post-hearing status report. If petitioner requests additional time before the immigration judge, the time for respondents to comply is automatically extended, and any representation that petitioner is not prepared to go forward is treated as a request for a continuance rather than a withdrawal of the bond hearing request. The court denied appointment of counsel without prejudice because the recommended relief made appointment unnecessary at that time.
Key Takeaways
- Detention exceeding six months under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(c), coupled with a pending BIA appeal and no final removal order, supported a due process right to a bond hearing on this record.
- The court joined district decisions recognizing an as-applied due process limit on mandatory detention, while noting that the Ninth Circuit had not decided whether § 1226(c) detainees always receive such a hearing.
- A disputed administrative-exhaustion record did not prevent relief where the petition raised only a prolonged-detention due process claim and no custody hearing had occurred.
- The recommended order placed the burden on respondents to prove danger or flight risk by clear and convincing evidence and required notice, counsel access, and a status report.
Why It Matters
This is a magistrate judge's findings and recommendation, not a final judgment. The assigned district judge must review it, and the order expressly allows seven days for objections, with responses due seven days later and a warning that failure to object may waive appellate review.
The decision illustrates how courts can grant meaningful habeas relief in mandatory-detention cases without first resolving contested exhaustion or the ultimate statutory basis for detention, provided the constitutional claim is limited to prolonged detention.