Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Osmar Enrique Garcia Xulu, a native of Guatemala, entered the United States without inspection on October 23, 2013 and lived in Virginia with an uncle. After a 2016 misdemeanor DUI arrest and release from state custody, he was taken into immigration custody and placed in removal proceedings. He was later released from immigration detention, though the parties disputed the exact mechanism: Petitioner alleged his family posted an immigration bond, while Respondents stated he was paroled under 8 U.S.C. § 1182(d)(5). Neither side supplied independent documentation resolving the precise type of parole or release.
Petitioner's removal proceedings were administratively closed on August 27, 2024, and he alleged that he held a valid driver's license and work authorization. He was re-detained on August 12, 2026 while riding as a passenger in a car driven by a noncitizen who appeared to be the target of immigration surveillance. Petitioner alleged he was not presented with any arrest warrant or documentation that his prior release had been revoked.
Petitioner filed an amended petition for a writ of habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2241. After the court issued an order to show cause, Respondents filed a return. In that return, Respondents acknowledged that Petitioner had previously been released pursuant to parole under 8 U.S.C. § 1182(d)(5), noted that courts have previously ordered release on this ground, and stated they would defer to the court as to the appropriate relief.
The Court’s Holding
Given Respondents' statements, the court declined to engage in a full analysis of the petition's claims. It observed that both Petitioner and Respondents agreed in their briefing that Petitioner had been previously released from immigration detention in 2016 on some form of parole or release. The court noted that many courts, including this one, have repeatedly held that a prior grant of release raises a liberty interest for the petitioner and entitles the petitioner to due process rights under procedural due process, citing Mohammadi v. LaRose and Isoev v. LaRose.
The court adopted its prior reasoning and found that due process required Petitioner's release. It granted the writ of habeas corpus and ordered Respondents to immediately release Petitioner from custody, subject to any conditions of his prior release that existed at the time he was re-detained.
The court further directed the parties to file a Joint Status Report by November 19, 2026 confirming that Petitioner has been released, and ordered the Clerk of Court to close the case.
Key Takeaways
- A prior grant of release from immigration detention, whether by bond or parole, can create a liberty interest that triggers procedural due process protections before re-detention.
- Where the government's return concedes prior release and defers to the court on the appropriate relief, the court may grant habeas relief without conducting a full merits analysis of the claims.
- The court's release order preserved the conditions of the petitioner's prior release that existed at the time of re-detention, rather than imposing new conditions.
- The court required a short-fuse joint status report to confirm compliance with the release order, reflecting the urgency of the habeas remedy.
- The court relied on its own recent precedent in Mohammadi v. LaRose and Isoev v. LaRose to conclude that the prior release raised a liberty interest requiring due process.
Why It Matters
This order illustrates how unresolved factual questions about the precise form of a noncitizen's prior release need not defeat habeas relief where the government concedes that release occurred and does not contest the legal consequence. The court treated the existence of some prior release, not its exact statutory label, as the operative fact giving rise to a liberty interest.
The decision also demonstrates the court applying its own recent precedent on prior-release liberty interests to grant immediate relief and close the case quickly, while leaving the precise terms of release tied to whatever conditions existed before re-detention. The short deadline for a joint status report underscores the court's expectation of prompt compliance with the release order.