California Case Summaries

NASH – Holland Koreatown Investors, LLC v. Nicholas Matranga — Federal court remands removed unlawful-detainer case to state court for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
NASH – Holland Koreatown Investors, LLC v. Nicholas Matranga
Court
U.S. District Court — Central District of California
Judge
Mark C. Scarsi (Donald Trump, 2020)
Date Decided
2026-11-16
Docket No.
2:26-cv-12390
Status
Unreported
Topics
removal jurisdiction, remand, unlawful detainer, federal question, civil rights removal, 28 U.S.C. 1443, diversity jurisdiction, forum defendant rule

Background

This case began as an unlawful-detainer action in Los Angeles County Superior Court, No. 26STUD06845, brought by NASH – Holland Koreatown Investors, LLC against Nicholas Matranga. A removing defendant sent the case to the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. On November 16, 2026, Judge Mark C. Scarsi remanded it on the court's own motion, using the court's standard remand form.

The court began with the rules for removal. Removal is a statutory right that is strictly construed against removal jurisdiction. The removing defendant bears the burden of showing original federal subject-matter jurisdiction. Because that jurisdiction cannot be waived, the court must remand whenever it appears before final judgment that jurisdiction is lacking, and the court may raise the issue itself. Judge Scarsi reviewed the notice of removal and the state-court records provided and concluded that jurisdiction was lacking.

The Court’s Holding

On federal-question jurisdiction, the court found that the complaint contains no claim arising under the Constitution, laws or treaties of the United States. It also found that the removing defendant had not alleged facts satisfying 28 U.S.C. § 1443. Even assuming the defendant invoked rights protected by explicit statutes on equal racial civil rights, the defendant identified no state statute or constitutional provision commanding state courts to ignore those rights. The defendant also pointed to nothing suggesting the state court would not enforce them. Conclusory statements without a factual basis cannot support removal under § 1443(1). Section 1443(2) did not help either, because it gives a removal privilege only to federal officers or agents, those acting with or for them, and state officers who refuse to enforce discriminatory state laws. The court also noted that the underlying action is an unlawful-detainer proceeding arising under and governed by California law.

On diversity, the court found that not every defendant is alleged to be diverse from every plaintiff. It found that the underlying unlawful-detainer action is a limited civil action not exceeding $25,000. It also found that the removing defendant is a California citizen, which implicates the forum-defendant bar of 28 U.S.C. § 1441(b)(2). The court remanded the case to the California Superior Court listed in the order for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. It denied the request to proceed in forma pauperis (ECF No. 3) and the motion to remand (ECF No. 9) as moot. The order did not rely on other grounds listed on the form, such as bankruptcy jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1334, whose boxes were left unmarked.

Key Takeaways

  • A removing defendant must show original federal jurisdiction, and removal statutes are strictly construed against removal.
  • A court may remand sua sponte whenever it appears that subject-matter jurisdiction is lacking, because the defect cannot be waived.
  • Removal under § 1443(1) requires facts showing that state law or the state court would deny enforcement of the asserted equal-civil-rights protections, not conclusory assertions.
  • Section 1443(2) is limited to federal officers or agents, those authorized to act with them, and state officers who refuse to enforce discriminatory state laws.
  • Diversity removal of a California unlawful-detainer action failed where complete diversity was not alleged, the action was a limited civil action not exceeding $25,000, and the removing defendant was a California citizen.

Why It Matters

The order shows how courts handle removals of summary state-court eviction cases. A defendant who cannot point to a federal claim in the complaint, concrete facts supporting § 1443, or true diversity will see the case returned to state court.

It is a short form order that decides jurisdiction on the notice of removal and state-court records alone. It does not reach the merits of the eviction and does not address any ground whose box was left unchecked.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top