Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Conjunction Junction, LLC filed a preliminary Builder's Remedy application with the City of Rancho Palos Verdes in April 2023. The application described four units with two deed-restricted for low income, plus large accessory structures. In July 2023, a City senior planner, Amy Seeraty, told the developer the application was incomplete. She also said the site lay within the City's landslide moratorium area and that an exclusion permit application would be required. In August 2023, the developer sued the City and Seeraty for a writ of mandate under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA). It also asserted a 42 U.S.C. section 1983 due process claim and challenged the moratorium.
After defendants demurred, the developer submitted a second preliminary application in October 2023. It described three residential units totaling 15,132 square feet, one deed-restricted for low income, within 76,093 total square feet of construction. The remaining space was for accessory structures and outdoor areas, including a large barn, indoor and outdoor arenas, storage buildings and 23 parking spaces. The trial court sustained a demurrer to the first amended pleading largely with leave to amend because the developer had not alleged a qualifying housing development project. The developer then filed its second amended petition and complaint, attaching the October 2023 application.
The trial court sustained the demurrer to that pleading without leave to amend and entered judgment for defendants. It concluded that the project was not a 'housing development project' consisting of 'residential units only,' and that it did not meet the mixed-use test requiring two-thirds residential square footage, because residential use was about 19.88 percent. It also sustained the demurrer to the section 1983 and moratorium claims. The developer appealed.
The Court’s Holding
The Court of Appeal (Second District, Division Five) affirmed in an unpublished opinion. The Builder's Remedy applies only to 'housing development projects.' The developer's briefing did not explain how its project qualified, and it did not dispute the trial court's primary conclusion that the October 2023 application did not describe one. The court treated that point as waived, citing the rule that an appellant must support its points with reasoned argument and authority. It therefore held that the writ of mandate claim failed and the City could not be compelled to approve the application. The opinion did not itself analyze the statutory definition.
The section 1983 claim was based on deprivation of rights under the Builder's Remedy. Because the developer did not allege facts showing a housing development project, it did not allege deprivation of a property interest. The third cause of action asserted that a Builder's Remedy project need not comply with the landslide moratorium, and it failed for the same reason. The court declined to develop the developer's alternative argument that the moratorium was not a 'public good' because the City had treated a different parcel differently. It also noted that the trial court had not ruled on the City's housing element or ripeness arguments and had not sustained the demurrer on mootness grounds, contrary to the developer's contentions.
The court found no abuse of discretion in denying leave to amend. The developer proposed to add allegations about retroactive application of statutes, the City's delaying conduct, written inconsistency findings, bad-faith use of the moratorium and the housing element's noncompliance. None of these cured the basic defect: the application was not for a housing development project. The developer had also had two earlier chances to cure that defect. The City and Seeraty, in her official capacity, were awarded costs on appeal.
Key Takeaways
- The Builder's Remedy covers only a 'housing development project,' so a developer must plead facts showing its project qualifies.
- An appellant who does not challenge the trial court's primary ground for sustaining a demurrer can lose the appeal through waiver, even when it raises other arguments.
- The court did not itself decide whether the project's accessory structures disqualified it. It rested on waiver and the pleading failure, and the opinion is unpublished and not citable under rule 8.1115.
- Section 1983 and moratorium-exemption claims that depend on Builder's Remedy status fail when the project is not pleaded as a qualifying housing development project.
- Proposed amendments about delay, bad faith or housing element compliance do not justify leave to amend when they leave the threshold project-qualification defect uncured.
Why It Matters
The decision shows that Builder's Remedy litigation can turn on the threshold question of project qualification before any question about the City's housing element or its conduct. Allegations of local obstruction do not matter if the pleaded application does not describe a housing development project as the statute defines it.
Because the ruling rests largely on waiver and is unpublished, it carries limited precedential value on how the HAA's 'residential units only' and mixed-use definitions apply to projects with large accessory uses. It is mainly a reminder of the importance of addressing the trial court's dispositive reasoning on appeal.