Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiffs Tony and Corina Falbo initiated a wrongful death action against William Parisi after his commercial dump truck struck and killed their 20-year-old daughter, Sidney, while she was riding her bicycle through an intersection crosswalk in Santa Rosa. At trial, conflicting accounts emerged regarding whether the bicyclist had stopped before entering the crosswalk or proceeded without stopping, as well as the driver's scanning maneuvers while executing a right turn.
Over plaintiffs' objections, the trial court permitted defense accident reconstruction expert Dr. Eric Rossetter to present two alternative collision scenarios—one positing that the bicyclist stopped and accelerated into the truck's path, and another positing that she turned into the crosswalk without stopping. Dr. Rossetter opined that under either scenario, the driver could not have avoided the collision within normal perception-reaction times, and the court admitted accompanying computer animations. The jury returned a verdict finding the driver was not negligent, and the trial court subsequently issued a postjudgment order awarding expert witness fees under Code of Civil Procedure section 998.
The Court’s Holding
The Court of Appeal affirmed the defense judgment, rejecting plaintiffs' contention that Dr. Rossetter's alternative scenarios were impermissibly speculative under Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California. The court explained that unlike a plaintiff bearing the burden of proof on causation, a defendant is not precluded from introducing alternative factual possibilities supported by physical evidence and circumstantial witness accounts to undermine the sufficiency of the plaintiff's case-in-chief.
Modifying its opinion upon denying rehearing, the panel addressed newly enacted Evidence Code section 801.1, which abrogated Kline v. Zimmer, Inc. by requiring defense medical causation experts to opine to a reasonable medical probability. The court held that section 801.1 is expressly restricted to medical causation and does not apply to accident reconstruction experts, confirming that the Legislature did not intend categorically to restrict defense experts in non-medical fields from presenting alternative explanatory scenarios.
The court additionally held that it lacked jurisdiction to review plaintiffs' challenge to the postjudgment order awarding section 998 expert witness fees. Because the underlying judgment was silent regarding costs and fees, and plaintiffs filed their notice of appeal before the trial court conducted hearings or announced its decision on the motion to tax costs, the subsequent cost award was not subsumed under the premature notice of appeal.
Key Takeaways
- Defense accident reconstruction experts may testify to alternative plausible collision scenarios to demonstrate that a defendant could not have avoided an accident under either possibility, even if the expert cannot declare either scenario more probable than not.
- Evidence Code section 801.1's requirement that defense experts testify to a reasonable probability is strictly confined to medical causation and does not extend to accident reconstruction or general defense expert testimony.
- Computer animations illustrating an expert witness's reconstruction opinions remain admissible demonstrative evidence so long as they accurately depict the expert's opinions and are not unduly inflammatory under Evidence Code section 352.
- A notice of appeal from a judgment silent as to costs does not subsume a subsequent postjudgment fee or cost award under Code of Civil Procedure section 998, requiring an independent notice of appeal once the postjudgment order is entered.
Why It Matters
This decision clarifies the scope of recently enacted Evidence Code section 801.1, confirming that its abrogation of Kline v. Zimmer, Inc. operates solely within the realm of medical causation testimony. The opinion protects the ability of defense reconstruction and liability experts to challenge a plaintiff's case-in-chief with alternative physical and circumstantial scenarios without having to establish a single affirmative scenario to a reasonable probability.
The ruling also serves as a crucial civil procedure warning for California appellate practitioners, reiterating that generic prospective language in a notice of appeal cannot cure the failure to file a timely separate appeal from a postjudgment order awarding statutory costs and section 998 fees.