California Case Summaries

In re D.G. CA2/3 filed 11/20/26 — Dependency orders affirmed except termination of parental rights is conditionally reversed for proper ICWA inquiry

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
In re D.G.
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Ashworth; Adams (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Hanasono
Date Decided
2026-11-20
Docket No.
B351431
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
dependency, juvenile court, ICWA inquiry, section 388 petition, restraining order, bonding study, parental-benefit exception, termination of parental rights

Background

Mother appealed juvenile court orders summarily denying her Welfare and Institutions Code section 388 petitions seeking reinstatement of reunification services, issuing a one-year restraining order under section 213.5 protecting the child's caregiver, and terminating parental rights after the court denied a continuance of the section 366.26 hearing and a bonding study and rejected the parental-benefit exception to adoption. Father separately challenged termination solely on the ground that DCFS and the juvenile court failed to conduct the initial inquiry required by the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) and California implementing law.

The dependency concerned D.G., born August 2024, who was removed shortly after birth amid evidence of prenatal drug exposure and placed with maternal aunt Ms. G. Mother repeatedly tested positive for methamphetamine during the reunification period while denying drug use, and DCFS reported that a purported hair-follicle test she submitted had been altered and was fraudulent. Reunification services were terminated in July 2025, and mother filed successive section 388 petitions in October 2025, February 2026, and March 2026.

At the April 8, 2026 section 366.26 hearing, the court denied mother's request for a continuance so her regular attorney could appear, heard testimony from the social worker, mother, and father, and terminated parental rights after finding the benefits of adoption by Ms. G. outweighed any detriment from severing the parent-child relationships. DCFS conceded the ICWA inquiry was inadequate and did not oppose conditional reversal as to father.

The Court’s Holding

The Court of Appeal held the juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in summarily denying mother's section 388 petitions. Her allegations of recent treatment participation and negative tests showed at most changing rather than changed circumstances, and neither petition made the required factual showing that further reunification would advance D.G.'s needs for stability and permanency rather than merely delay them.

Substantial evidence supported the restraining order protecting the caregiver, including a threatening text message the court found mother and father sent, prior baseless accusations, and the caregiver's testimony of fear. The court also acted within its discretion in denying a continuance of the section 366.26 hearing and in refusing a belated bonding study request as to an 18-month-old preverbal child, and substantial evidence supported rejection of the parental-benefit exception because D.G.'s positive visits did not outweigh the security and permanence of adoption.

Because DCFS failed to contact paternal grandmother and follow up on paternal relatives' alleged tribal grants, the court conditionally reversed the order terminating parental rights as to both parents and remanded for proper ICWA inquiry of available and ascertainable extended paternal relatives, with reinstatement of the termination order if the inquiry shows no reason to believe D.G. is an Indian child.

Key Takeaways

  • After reunification services end, a section 388 petition must factually show how the requested change will advance the child's needs for stability and permanency, not merely reward a parent's recent progress.
  • A juvenile court may rely on the full dependency file, including caregiver safety reports, when deciding whether to issue a section 213.5 restraining order.
  • A belated request for a bonding study may be denied where the child is very young and preverbal and the study would delay permanency without materially assisting the Caden C. analysis.
  • Positive visitation alone does not establish the parental-benefit exception where the child shows no distress at separation and adoption offers security and permanence.
  • Deficient ICWA initial inquiry requires conditional reversal of termination as to both parents and remand for documented inquiry of extended paternal relatives.

Why It Matters

The opinion applies In re Caden C.'s framework to a preverbal toddler whose only contact with mother was monitored visitation, confirming that courts may weigh the child's age, lack of prior custody, and absence of separation distress against the benefits of adoption without ordering expert evidence in every case.

The ICWA portion illustrates that even where a tribe reports no registration, the agency's continuing duty requires documented inquiry of identified extended family members, and failure at that initial stage can unwind an otherwise final termination order.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top