Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
On November 13, 2026, Magistrate Judge Jeremy D. Peterson of the Eastern District of California (No. 2:26-cv-3678) issued an order to show cause in Jady Hodge's petition for a writ of mandate and request for an immediate stay. The petition named the Superior Court of California, County of Sacramento, Chad Couchot, Kee Kim, and UC Davis as defendants. It was addressed to the California Court of Appeal, Third Appellate District.
After reviewing the complaint, the court found that it failed to establish a basis for subject matter jurisdiction. It gave Hodge fourteen days to show cause why the action should not be dismissed. The court explained that a district court has an independent duty to determine its jurisdiction, and that a case presumptively lies outside federal jurisdiction unless the complaint shows otherwise.
The Court’s Holding
On federal question jurisdiction, the court found none on the face of the complaint. Hodge made only a passing reference to the Fourteenth Amendment, which the court said is insufficient under the well-pleaded complaint rule. The court also noted that Hodge alleged his claims arise out of California Civil Procedure Code section 170.3(d), a state statute.
On diversity jurisdiction, the court observed that Hodge listed his own residence and the defendants' residences as California. It concluded there did not appear to be a basis for diversity jurisdiction on the face of the complaint. The order did not separately analyze the amount in controversy.
The court ordered Hodge to show cause within fourteen days why the action should not be dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. It warned that failure to respond would result in a recommendation that the action be dismissed without prejudice. The order does not dismiss the case and does not discuss the request for a stay.
Key Takeaways
- A federal complaint must show a basis for subject matter jurisdiction, and a case is presumptively outside federal jurisdiction unless it does.
- A passing reference to a federal constitutional provision does not create federal question jurisdiction under the well-pleaded complaint rule when the claims are pleaded under state law.
- Diversity jurisdiction requires complete diversity and an amount in controversy above $75,000; a complaint listing all parties as California residents does not appear to support it.
- The order is only a show-cause directive, and the next step turns on whether Hodge responds within fourteen days.
Why It Matters
The order shows the early screening role of a federal court when a filing is directed to a state appellate court and pleads state-law claims. The court did not dismiss immediately. It gave the plaintiff a chance to establish jurisdiction before any recommendation of dismissal.
It also reflects that a federal court may raise its own jurisdiction at any time. Because the order is a procedural show-cause directive, it does not finally resolve the case.