California Case Summaries

In re K.C. (Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services v. S.H.) — Court of Appeal Affirms Reasonable Reunification Services Findings Despite Teen’s Refusal of Contact After Abuse

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
In re K.C.
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Goorvitch (Gavin Newsom, 2026); Lui; Chavez
Date Decided
2026-11-13
Docket No.
B347990
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
juvenile dependency, reunification services, reasonable services, visitation, conjoint therapy, forfeiture, substantial evidence

Background

In unpublished appeals Nos. B347990 and B351638, mother S.H. challenged juvenile court findings that the Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) provided reasonable reunification services for her daughter K.C., born in 2011. DCFS received a referral in September 2024 alleging mother physically abused K.C. K.C. reported being punched, choked, and struck with a speaker and an ice roller, and a forensic medical exam found findings consistent with her report of being hit on the face with a speaker. Over DCFS's objection, and with mother's counsel urging it, the court placed K.C. with her adult half-sister, T.W.

On January 21, 2025, mother pleaded no contest to an amended section 300 petition alleging physical abuse. The court declared K.C. a dependent, removed her from mother, and ordered reunification services. The case plan included twice-monthly two-hour visits, with DCFS to confer with K.C.'s therapist about visits in a therapeutic setting. K.C. consistently said she did not want contact with mother. Her therapist repeatedly reported she was not ready for conjoint therapy. One monitored visit took place at a Starbucks in October 2025, and a Child and Family Team meeting was held December 29, 2025.

At the six-month hearing (August 1, 2025) the court called reasonable services a "close call" but found them reasonable. At the 12-month hearing (December 31, 2025) it found by clear and convincing evidence that DCFS made reasonable efforts, ordered additional services, and set an April 2026 review. Mother appealed both findings.

The Court’s Holding

The court assumed without deciding that the findings are appealable and reviewed them for substantial evidence, accounting for the clear-and-convincing standard. It held that mother forfeited her complaint about K.C.'s placement with T.W. She had asked for that placement, did not object at disposition or later hearings, and never filed a section 388 petition or asked the court to change placement. The court added that DCFS cannot be faulted for following a placement order mother herself advocated.

On the six-month period, the court stressed that the standard is reasonableness under the circumstances, not perfection. Given the serious abuse, K.C.'s refusal of contact, and monthly social worker outreach about visitation and therapy, the efforts to arrange therapy and visits were sufficient. Not assigning a cultural broker at that early stage could not have changed K.C.'s unwillingness to have contact.

On the 12-month period, K.C. attended at least 11 individual therapy sessions between August and December 2025, and her therapist repeatedly opined she was not ready for conjoint therapy. DCFS acted reasonably in letting that process continue. Mother showed no duty to find a new therapist, nor any evidence another therapist would have recommended conjoint therapy sooner. The court rejected the "veto" claim, noting the case plan required DCFS to confer with the therapist, DCFS encouraged the Starbucks visit and further contact, and mother requested no specific enforcement beyond the team meeting, which the court granted. The December 2025 team meeting's timing and the cultural broker delay did not matter, because nothing showed an earlier meeting or broker would have changed the outcome. The court also denied DCFS's request for judicial notice of a criminal protective order, which was not before the trial court. The orders were affirmed.

Key Takeaways

  • Reunification services are judged by whether they were reasonable under the circumstances, not whether they were the best possible.
  • A parent who asked for a relative placement in the juvenile court forfeits an appellate argument that the placement undermined reunification, particularly without seeking modification below.
  • Where a child has been seriously abused and refuses contact, the court may rely on therapist recommendations and the child's well-being when assessing whether visitation and conjoint therapy efforts were reasonable.
  • A parent who wants specific enforcement of visitation should ask for it in the juvenile court, because the court is not obliged to devise solutions on its own.
  • The opinion is unpublished and may not be cited or relied on under California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115.

Why It Matters

The opinion applies settled reasonable-services law to a difficult but common situation: a parent who is complying with the case plan while an abused adolescent resists contact. It confirms that a child's reluctance, supported by clinical advice, does not by itself make services unreasonable when the agency keeps encouraging contact.

Because it is unpublished, it has no precedential value, but it shows how the court treats forfeiture and the need for specific requests in dependency litigation.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top