Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
The Los Angeles Department of Children and Family Services filed a dependency petition after reports that father B.V. physically abused ten-year-old Br.V., who had serious behavioral and mental-health needs, and after the parents did not follow through on referrals for services. The juvenile court took jurisdiction under Welfare and Institutions Code section 300, subdivision (b)(1), dismissed the subdivision (j) allegations and allegations as to the two other children, and ordered, without objection, mother J.T. to participate in random drug testing and other services.
Mother had reported occasional marijuana use, tested positive on one of two drug tests, and did not object to the testing requirement at disposition. On appeal she challenged only that requirement; dependency jurisdiction was uncontested.
The Court’s Holding
The Court of Appeal held the challenge was forfeited because Mother raised no contemporaneous objection and her attorney expressly said she was open to testing. The court declined to excuse forfeiture because the asserted issue—whether a service not reasonably related to the conditions supporting jurisdiction could be imposed—was not an important legal issue requiring review.
The court also held the order would be affirmed on the merits. Under section 362, subdivision (a), a disposition order need not be limited to the conduct that produced jurisdiction, and the juvenile court has broad discretion to protect the child. Mother’s marijuana use, Minor’s elevated care needs, and the need to assess whether drug use affected her ability to secure services supported the testing condition.
Key Takeaways
- A parent who fails to object to a juvenile disposition condition ordinarily forfeits appellate challenge to that condition.
- Express willingness to accept testing at the disposition hearing reinforces forfeiture rather than preserving the issue.
- A dependency disposition condition need not be confined to the conduct that established jurisdiction.
- Drug testing can be a reasonable means of assessing whether parental substance use impairs the ability to obtain services for a child with significant behavioral needs.
- The Court of Appeal affirmed the juvenile court’s order.
Why It Matters
This unpublished opinion applies ordinary forfeiture rules to a parent’s unobjected-to drug-testing condition and treats the issue as insufficiently important to excuse forfeiture.
It also confirms broad juvenile-court discretion to impose reasonable disposition services beyond the conduct underlying jurisdiction, including testing tied to assessing parental capacity to meet a child’s special needs.