California Case Summaries

Torres v. Gonzalez — Denial of Summary Judgment Discovery Continuance Affirmed Where Party Failed to Specify Essential Controverting Facts

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Torres v. Gonzalez
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Chavez; Lui; Richardson (Gavin Newsom, 2024)
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
B346640
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
Code of Civil Procedure section 437c(h), summary judgment continuance, discovery necessity, breach of fiduciary duty, reply declarations

Background

Daniel Torres and Albert Gonzalez, Jr. each maintained a 50 percent ownership share in Alda Management, Inc., a real estate management and leasing entity. In January 2023, Torres filed a lawsuit against Gonzalez alleging breach of fiduciary duty and seeking an accounting, contending Gonzalez improperly excluded him from operations, withheld corporate records, and issued unauthorized corporate checks. Gonzalez moved for summary judgment, arguing the claims were barred by the applicable statutes of limitations and that Torres lacked standing because Alda Management was a mere pass-through company holding no right to the disputed funds.

Instead of filing a substantive opposition or a separate statement disputing Gonzalez's material facts, Torres requested a 120-day continuance under California Code of Civil Procedure section 437c, subdivision (h). Counsel for Torres declared that a neutral forensic accountant had been appointed in a separate Los Angeles County Superior Court proceeding and that reviewing Alda Management's incoming and outgoing funds was necessary to oppose the motion, pointing to purported discrepancies in Alda Management's 2021 tax return.

Gonzalez filed reply declarations from the forensic accountant—who clarified his court appointment did not involve Alda Management's finances—and Alda Management's certified public accountant. The Los Angeles County Superior Court denied the continuance request, determining Torres failed to identify the specific essential facts sought or show diligence, and granted summary judgment because Gonzalez's evidence established the claims lacked merit and fell outside the limitations period.

The Court’s Holding

The Second District Court of Appeal affirmed. The court held that the trial court did not abuse its discretion under Code of Civil Procedure section 437c, subdivision (h), because an applicant must detail the specific essential facts expected to be obtained and demonstrate why they could not then be presented. Torres's broad declaration stating a general need to understand funds moving through the entity failed to specify any controverting facts or explain how the pending accounting would address Gonzalez's statute of limitations defense.

The appellate court further held that the trial court's consideration of declarations submitted on reply did not constitute reversible error under Article VI, section 13 of the California Constitution. Even if new evidence in reply requires an opportunity to respond, Torres suffered no prejudice because he offered no substantive rebuttal evidence or argument capable of changing the outcome, failed to file a separate statement disputing Gonzalez's prima facie showing, and could not show that the continuance denial depended on the reply declarations.

Key Takeaways

  • A request for a mandatory summary judgment continuance under Code of Civil Procedure section 437c, subdivision (h) requires declarations specifying the concrete, essential controverting facts sought rather than generalized desires to review financial records.
  • Relying on an ongoing accounting in an unrelated matter will not justify a discovery continuance absent evidence that the investigation actually encompasses the entity's records and will yield admissible controverting evidence.
  • Considering new reply declarations without sur-reply is harmless error unless the appellant proves prejudice by identifying specific rebuttal evidence that would have altered the disposition of the motion.

Why It Matters

The decision reiterates strict adherence to the statutory prerequisites of section 437c, subdivision (h), confirming that parties cannot treat discovery continuances as automatic shields against summary judgment. Practitioners opposing summary judgment cannot rely solely on continuance requests while skipping substantive oppositions and separate statements without risking immediate forfeiture and entry of judgment.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top