Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Original plaintiff Kasim Tarin provided notice to the California Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA) on March 24, 2023, and filed a first amended complaint asserting class and representative Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA) claims against employer RADC Enterprises, Inc. After Kasim died in January 2025, the trial court allowed his daughter, Nafisa Tarin, to continue the class claims as successor in interest, but held she lacked standing to maintain the PAGA claim because she was never an RADC employee.
Nafisa Tarin then moved for leave to amend the complaint to substitute Monica Praster, a former RADC employee from 2021 to May 2024, as the named representative plaintiff for the PAGA claim without altering the underlying factual allegations. Praster had also submitted an administrative notice to the LWDA in February 2025 and filed a separate PAGA action in April 2025.
The trial court denied leave to amend, ruling that PAGA standing and administrative exhaustion requirements precluded substituting another plaintiff whose employment postdated the 2018 class period inception and whose notice was non-contemporaneous. Tarin petitioned for a writ of mandate.
The Court’s Holding
The Court of Appeal granted the petition and issued a peremptory writ of mandate directing the trial court to grant leave to amend. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 473, subdivision (a)(1), courts liberally permit amendments to substitute real parties in interest when the amendment does not alter the factual basis of the suit or prejudice the defendant.
The court held that Praster qualified as an aggrieved employee under former Labor Code section 2699, subdivision (c), because she worked for RADC between 2021 and 2024 and allegedly suffered the same violations during the one-year limitations window preceding Kasim's 2023 notice. The court rejected RADC's focus on the 2018 class period, explaining that representative PAGA actions are independent of class claims.
Following Hutcheson v. Superior Court, the court held that PAGA exhaustion under Labor Code section 2699.3 governs commencing actions rather than continuing pending suits. Because Kasim's timely notice satisfied notice purposes and Praster exhausted her notice before seeking substitution, the timing of her notice did not bar substitution or relation back.
Key Takeaways
- Trial courts must liberally permit amendments under Code of Civil Procedure section 473 to substitute a qualified aggrieved employee as representative plaintiff in a PAGA action after the original plaintiff dies.
- An employee possesses PAGA standing for substitution if employed and subjected to alleged violations during the statutory limitations period, regardless of earlier class period dates.
- Labor Code section 2699.3 administrative exhaustion applies to commencing actions, meaning a substitute plaintiff's subsequent exhaustion does not preclude relation back to a timely complaint.
- A PAGA plaintiff acts as an agent and proxy of the state, so substituting an aggrieved employee continues the state's enforcement action rather than effecting an improper claim assignment.
Why It Matters
The decision confirms California appellate precedent establishing that representative PAGA actions survive the death of the original named plaintiff through the substitution of another aggrieved employee.
By aligning liberal amendment and relation-back doctrines with PAGA's statutory scheme, the ruling ensures that representative enforcement on behalf of the state is not thwarted by the death or disqualification of an initial proxy.