Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
In March 1998, Jose Damian Garcia pleaded no contest to attempted first degree robbery. The trial court suspended imposition of sentence and placed Garcia on probation for three years. In June 1999, the court revoked probation following a violation and imposed a two-year middle term in state prison, which was later reflected in an amended abstract of judgment.
In December 2025, Garcia filed a postconviction motion for resentencing under the California Racial Justice Act of 2020 (Penal Code section 745). The superior court denied the motion in January 2026, finding Garcia's claims conclusory, unsupported, contradicted by the record of conviction, and legally erroneous, and concluding that he failed to establish a prima facie basis for relief.
After Garcia appealed, appointed counsel filed an opening brief raising no issues under People v. Delgadillo. Garcia filed a pro per supplemental brief reiterating his statutory claims and requesting that the appellate court grant discovery under the Racial Justice Act and appoint counsel.
The Court’s Holding
The Second District Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, holding that the postconviction order denying Garcia's motion for resentencing was not appealable because the superior court lacked jurisdiction to provide relief under the California Racial Justice Act. Under Penal Code section 745, subdivision (j), a defendant whose judgment is already final can raise an RJA claim only through a petition for writ of habeas corpus or a motion under Penal Code section 1473.7.
The court held that Garcia was not entitled to independent record review under People v. Wende or Anders v. California because he appealed a postconviction order rather than his direct conviction. Although the panel considered Garcia's supplemental brief pursuant to Delgadillo, it declined to conduct a discretionary independent review and concluded it lacked jurisdiction to grant his requests for discovery or appointed counsel.
Key Takeaways
- An order denying a postconviction motion for resentencing under the California Racial Justice Act is not appealable when the underlying judgment is already final.
- A defendant challenging a final judgment under Penal Code section 745 must proceed exclusively through a petition for writ of habeas corpus or a motion to vacate under section 1473.7.
- Independent record review under Wende and Anders does not apply to postconviction relief appeals, though courts must consider supplemental contentions submitted under Delgadillo.
- When an appellate court lacks jurisdiction over an unappealable postconviction order, it has no authority to grant ancillary relief such as statutory discovery or appointment of counsel.
Why It Matters
The decision reinforces California appellate precedent establishing that trial courts lack jurisdiction to entertain freestanding postconviction motions under the Racial Justice Act once a conviction is final. By affirming that RJA challenges to final judgments must be brought via habeas corpus or section 1473.7, the ruling bars direct appeals from unauthorized postconviction motions and forecloses appellate consideration of related procedural requests.