Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Sunil Ingle worked as a software engineer for Criteo from January to November 2022. Criteo said it fired him for poor performance and insubordination; Ingle said the firing retaliated against him for raising concerns that Criteo's web scraping and purported ad-fraud practices were unethical or illegal. He sued under California Labor Code section 1102.5 and for wrongful termination in violation of public policy. ECF No. 47.
The court described two conversations Ingle had with coworkers about potential ad fraud, a disputed September 20, 2022 email he said he sent to Criteo's internal Speak Up complaint address, and a January 31, 2023 Speak Up complaint submitted almost three months after his termination. Criteo moved for summary judgment, arguing Ingle reported nothing protected before termination and would have been fired anyway for performance.
The Court’s Holding
The court held Ingle's conversation with product manager Ben Geller was not protected activity because Geller lacked authority over Ingle or authority to investigate or correct the violation. His discussion with supervisor Norman Shi about ad-fraud prevention technology did not show Shi understood it as a report of legal violations, so it did not establish employer awareness of protected activity.
Applying the sham-affidavit rule, the court struck Ingle's declaration to the extent it contradicted his deposition testimony that he sent nothing to Speak Up during employment and had only two ad-fraud conversations. The unauthenticated September 20, 2022 email was a draft, not protected activity. With no prima facie retaliation showing, the court granted summary judgment on both counts and dismissed the claims with prejudice; Criteo's Daubert motion was terminated as moot.
Key Takeaways
- Under section 1102.5, a report to a coworker without authority to investigate or correct the alleged violation is not protected activity.
- A retaliation plaintiff must show the employer knew of protected activity before the adverse action; ambiguous technical discussions may not convey a report of legal violations.
- A declaration contradicting clear prior deposition admissions can be stricken as a sham affidavit at summary judgment.
- An unsent draft complaint does not constitute protected whistleblowing activity.
Why It Matters
The decision illustrates how evidentiary foundation and consistency can determine whistleblower retaliation cases at summary judgment, even where an employee sincerely believed company practices were unlawful.
The court granted judgment on both the statutory retaliation claim and its derivative public-policy claim, dismissing the action with prejudice and closing the case.