Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff D. Scott Mattson filed a pro se action asserting claims for conversion, unjust enrichment, and equitable relief against an unidentified individual, John Doe, after inadvertently disclosing his cryptocurrency wallet recovery seed phrase during fraudulent phone calls involving a spoofed website. The perpetrator transferred approximately $305,215 worth of digital assets out of Mattson's wallets.
Using blockchain analytics, Mattson traced portions of the stolen cryptocurrency—including Ripple (XRP), Ethereum (ETH), and Bitcoin (BTC)—into customer accounts at foreign cryptocurrency exchanges WhiteBIT and KuCoin, which were joined as relief defendants. WhiteBIT indicated that its deposited funds had already been converted and withdrawn, while KuCoin placed a temporary administrative hold set to expire on November 22, 2026.
Mattson filed emergency motions seeking an ex parte temporary restraining order to freeze the traceable assets, leave to effect alternative service of process under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(f)(3) by delivering a non-fungible token (NFT) to the recipient wallet addresses and emailing the foreign exchange entities, and leave to participate in electronic case filing (CM/ECF).
The Court’s Holding
The district court granted the ex parte temporary restraining order, enjoining Doe and the exchange defendants from dissipating, transferring, or converting the traceable crypto assets through December 3, 2026. The court determined that Mattson established a strong likelihood of success on his conversion claim and demonstrated irreparable harm because cryptocurrency poses a heightened risk of rapid, irreversible dissipation, and the unknown identity of the perpetrator makes an ordinary money damages remedy ineffective. In light of the absence of identifiable damages to Doe, the court exercised its discretion under Rule 65(c) to waive the requirement of an injunction bond.
However, the court denied without prejudice Mattson’s motion for leave to effect alternative service of the summons and complaint. While authorizing Mattson to provide informal actual notice of the restraining order via NFT transfer to Doe and email to the exchanges, the court held that service of original process requires greater diligence. Specifically, Mattson had to exhaust subpoenas to the exchanges to ascertain Doe's contact information before resorting to NFT service, and he had to address whether email service on foreign entities in Lithuania and the Seychelles is compatible with the Hague Service Convention.
Finally, the court granted Mattson's motion for leave to file documents electronically under local district procedures after finding that he satisfied technical and procedural prerequisites.
Key Takeaways
- A plaintiff pursuing stolen cryptocurrency against an anonymous defendant can secure an ex parte asset freeze under Rule 65 by demonstrating that digital assets are traceable to specific exchange accounts and face imminent dissipation once temporary platform holds lapse.
- Serving actual notice of an emergency restraining order by novel digital channels like NFT airdrops or emails does not automatically authorize formal service of a summons and complaint under Rule 4(f)(3).
- Before a court will permit service of process on an anonymous crypto defendant by NFT, the plaintiff must exercise reasonable diligence, including pursuing third-party subpoenas to custodial exchanges to uncover identifiable contact details.
- When seeking alternative email service on foreign corporate defendants under Rule 4(f)(3), litigants must specifically brief whether the destination countries are signatories to the Hague Service Convention and whether the treaty preempts or permits email service in those jurisdictions.
Why It Matters
This decision illustrates the procedural mechanics federal courts employ to preserve stolen digital assets while maintaining strict constitutional and treaty-based safeguards around service of process. Although courts recognize the extreme urgency of freezing cryptocurrency before it is laundered through international exchanges, they remain reluctant to allow experimental service methods like NFT airdrops until standard investigative avenues, such as exchange subpoenas, are thoroughly pursued.