Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
People Center, Inc., doing business as Rippling, and Deel, Inc. are competitors offering workforce-management, payroll, and human-resources software. Rippling's operative First Amended Complaint alleges that Deel and its executives Alex and Phillipe Bouaziz recruited Rippling employee Keith O'Brien to funnel confidential trade-secret information to Deel, asserting federal RICO, Defend Trade Secrets Act, and state-law claims. Deel later asserted eight counterclaims against Rippling, O'Brien, and Rippling's chief executive Parker Conrad; the court compelled arbitration of some counterclaims, dismissed others, and left a narrowed false-advertising counterclaim pending.
The present dispute arose from Deel's Joint Discovery Letter seeking communications between O'Brien's counsel and Rippling's separate counsel. Rippling resisted on common-interest-doctrine grounds, arguing the doctrine prevents disclosure to a third party from waiving attorney-client privilege, and the parties disputed whether federal common law or Irish privilege law governed communications involving Irish attorneys. After briefing, a factual record that included the Cooperation Agreement between Rippling and O'Brien, and a hearing at which all parties' counsel participated, the court granted Deel's request to compel in part and denied it in part.
The Court’s Holding
The court rejected Rippling's argument that the Cooperation Agreement, signed March 27, 2025, itself established a common legal interest between Rippling and O'Brien. The agreement principally arranged settlement of the Irish proceedings in exchange for O'Brien's cooperation, and Rippling's obligation to strike out the Irish case remained conditional on O'Brien's compliance, so the Irish proceeding—and the parties' adversity—continued until Rippling dismissed it on August 1, 2025. From that dismissal forward, the court found, O'Brien and Rippling shared a common legal interest in preparing to defend against possible Deel counterclaims, even though some measure of adversity could remain.
A common legal interest alone did not protect every later communication. The court required an individualized, communication-by-communication assessment of whether each withheld document furthered a joint legal strategy, and it ordered Rippling to produce by November 16, 2026 all responsive pre-dismissal documents and communications withheld solely on common-interest grounds and not otherwise protected. For post-dismissal materials, Rippling must serve a privilege log by the same date identifying each withheld item's Bates number, date and timestamp, authors, recipients, privilege basis, asserted common interest, and the legal strategy furthered; disputed entries are left to meet-and-confer, a renewed discovery dispute letter, and possible in camera review.
Applying the touch-base analysis, the court held that United States privilege law governs the March 26, 2025 through August 1, 2025 communications between Irish counsel, because the United States has the predominant and most direct and compelling interest in their confidentiality—those communications advanced the U.S. proceeding. Because Rippling advanced no basis under U.S. privilege law for withholding the pre-agreement communications between O'Brien's Irish counsel and Rippling's Irish counsel, those communications must be produced.
Key Takeaways
- A cooperation or settlement agreement does not automatically create a common legal interest while the parties remain adversaries in unresolved litigation.
- The court identified dismissal of the Irish proceeding on August 1, 2025, rather than execution of the Cooperation Agreement on March 27, 2025, as the point when a common legal interest between Rippling and O'Brien could exist.
- Communications made before that dismissal must be produced if the common interest doctrine was the sole asserted basis for withholding them and no other privilege or protection applies.
- Later communications are not automatically protected; Rippling must support each withholding decision with a detailed privilege-log entry showing both an applicable privilege and furtherance of a joint legal strategy.
- The court applied United States privilege law under the touch-base analysis and established procedures for resolving remaining disputes, including meet-and-confer, a renewed discovery letter, and possible in camera review.
Why It Matters
The order separates the existence of a common legal interest from the additional requirement that a communication advance a joint legal strategy, and it shows why the timing and conditional terms of a settlement matter: an agreement to cooperate did not eliminate adversity while the underlying Irish claims remained pending. It also illustrates that a written agreement is neither necessary nor sufficient for the doctrine—courts scrutinize its purpose and the parties' actual alignment.
The ruling provides a partial production order rather than a blanket rejection or acceptance of privilege. Its logging requirements and follow-up procedures preserve communication-specific disputes for later resolution, while the choice-of-law analysis prevents Irish privilege law from independently blocking the specified pre-dismissal communications.