California Case Summaries

Mery Camila Cahuenas Silva v. Markwayne Mullin et al. — Magistrate Judge Grants Habeas Corpus on Procedural Due Process Claim, Orders Immediate Release of Asylum Seeker

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Mery Camila Cahuenas Silva v. Markwayne Mullin et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Central District of California
Judge
Rozella A. Oliver
Date Decided
2026-11-07
Docket No.
5:26-cv-06313
Status
Unreported
Topics
habeas corpus, immigration detention, procedural due process, asylum seekers, bond hearings, administrative exhaustion, Mathews v. Eldridge, liberty interest

Background

Mery Camila Cahuenas Silva, a citizen of Ecuador, entered the United States in August 2021 on a valid tourist visa that expired in February 2022. Approximately three years later, in September 2024, she applied for asylum, and that application remained pending when immigration authorities arrested and detained her on September 22, 2026, while she was exiting an airplane at Los Angeles International Airport. She was transported to the Adelanto ICE Processing Center, where she was detained at the time of the order.

On October 20, 2026, Cahuenas Silva received a custody hearing before an immigration judge, who denied bond after finding that she presented a flight risk. She filed a habeas corpus petition on October 26, 2026, challenging her arrest and detention on due process, Fourth Amendment, Immigration and Nationality Act, and Administrative Procedure Act grounds. Respondents filed an answer on November 3, 2026, and Cahuenas Silva filed a traverse on November 5, 2026.

Respondents argued that Cahuenas Silva had to exhaust administrative remedies by appealing the bond denial before seeking federal habeas relief, and that the bond hearing she received foreclosed relief on her due process and other claims. The court addressed the procedural due process claim first, applying the two-step framework used in immigration detention cases.

The Court’s Holding

The court first determined whether Cahuenas Silva had a protected liberty interest. Although she overstayed her visa, the court found that she continued to pursue immigration proceedings by applying for asylum and was permitted to remain in the United States until the application was decided. Following numerous other courts in the Ninth Circuit addressing similar facts, the court concluded that the government acquiesced to her continued presence, thereby vesting in her a liberty interest in remaining out of custody.

Having found a protected liberty interest, the court applied the three Mathews v. Eldridge factors. First, Cahuenas Silva had a substantial private interest in her own liberty that was adversely affected by her detention. Second, the risk of erroneous deprivation was high because she was not given a pre-deprivation opportunity to be heard on the justification for her detention. Because civil immigration detention is nonpunitive in purpose and effect, the justification for detention must outweigh the protected liberty interest to satisfy due process. Third, although the government has an interest in enforcing immigration laws and protecting public safety, its interest in detaining her without procedural safeguards was low; immigration-court detention hearings are routine and impose minimal effort and cost.

The court concluded that the Mathews factors weighed in favor of finding that her arrest and detention violated due process, and that immediate release was the appropriate remedy. The court also held that exhaustion is prudential rather than jurisdictional and should be excused because the petition raised a constitutional due process challenge that an immigration judge lacks jurisdiction to adjudicate. The court granted the Petition as to the procedural due process claim, Count Two, denied the Petition's remaining claims as moot, ordered respondents to release Cahuenas Silva immediately subject to reasonable conditions, enjoined further detention absent strict compliance with due process and applicable law, required a notice of compliance within two court days, and directed the clerk to enter judgment for the petitioner and close the case.

Key Takeaways

  • Asylum seekers who remain in the United States with pending applications can have a protected liberty interest in staying out of custody, even if they initially entered on temporary visas that later expired.
  • Immigration detention without a pre-deprivation opportunity to be heard creates a high risk of erroneous deprivation that weighs heavily in the due process analysis.
  • The government's interest in detaining asylum seekers without procedural safeguards is low, particularly when immigration-court detention hearings are routine and impose minimal burden.
  • Exhaustion of administrative remedies is prudential rather than jurisdictional in habeas cases and can be excused when the petition raises constitutional challenges that immigration judges lack jurisdiction to decide.
  • Federal courts have flexibility to order immediate release as a remedy when immigration detention violates procedural due process, and may require prompt compliance reporting.

Why It Matters

This decision reinforces the growing consensus among federal courts in the Ninth Circuit that asylum seekers with pending applications have a constitutionally protected liberty interest in remaining free from detention. By applying the Mathews v. Eldridge framework and finding that the government's interest in detention without adequate procedures is low, the court provides a clear analytical path for other asylum seekers challenging their detention.

The ruling also clarifies that exhaustion requirements do not bar federal habeas review of constitutional challenges to immigration detention, even when administrative appeals are available. That removes a significant procedural obstacle for detained asylum seekers seeking immediate relief and affirms the role of federal courts in protecting due process rights in the immigration context.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top