California Case Summaries

McLellan v. Google LLC — Court Orders Amended Patent Infringement Contentions But Refuses to Strike Them Entirely

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Mark McLellan v. Google LLC
Court
U.S. District Court — Northern District of California
Judge
Peter H. Kang (magistrate judge)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
3:26-cv-04101
Status
Unreported
Topics
patent infringement contentions, Patent Local Rule 3-1, discovery management, claim chart specificity, Google Local Search, U.S. Patent No. 8,849,807

Background

Mark McLellan sued Google LLC for allegedly infringing U.S. Patent No. 8,849,807 through Google's "Local Search" ranking systems and methods. Under Patent Local Rule 3-1, a patentee must identify each accused instrumentality and chart specifically where every limitation of each asserted claim is found, with contentions amendable only by court order on a showing of good cause.

All discovery matters were referred to Magistrate Judge Peter H. Kang. Google asked the court to strike McLellan's August 31, 2026 infringement contentions or require amendment before discovery, arguing they merely parroted claim language without identifying specific Google features. McLellan responded that his contentions gave reasonable notice to the extent information was available and that he lacked discovery or public sources.

The court resolved the parties' Further Joint Letter Brief without oral argument, exercising its broad discretion to manage discovery and enforce the Patent Local Rules.

The Court’s Holding

The court found two fundamental flaws. For claim elements 1(e)–1(h), 1(s), 4(j), 4(m)–4(o), and 4(r), the contentions said Google's Local Search "must necessarily" perform claimed functions without saying where or how. The court held that identifying a function and asserting it must be performed does not satisfy Rule 3-1(c)'s requirement to identify specifically where each limitation is found.

For claim elements 1(o), 1(p), 1(r), 1(u), 1(v), 1(x), and corresponding claim 4 limitations, the contentions essentially repeated or slightly rearranged the claim language. Pointing to Google Maps search results showed an alleged result, not where or how the claimed computer-executable instructions performed the function. The court held this, too, failed to give reasonable notice.

Google's motion was granted in part: McLellan must amend and serve compliant contentions by December 18, 2026, though the parties may mutually extend that deadline. The court denied Google's request to strike the contentions entirely and resolved Dkts. 77 and 83.

Key Takeaways

  • Infringement contentions must explain where and how each claimed function is performed; asserting that an accused system "must necessarily" perform a function is insufficient under Patent Local Rule 3-1(c).
  • Merely paraphrasing or rearranging claim language, or pointing to observable search results, does not identify the claimed components or instructions with the required specificity.
  • A patentee's lack of discovery or public technical information does not excuse compliance with the Patent Local Rules, because the patentee should still articulate its theory of where and how the accused system works.
  • Courts may order targeted amendment of deficient contentions rather than striking them wholesale, preserving the case while enforcing fair-notice requirements.

Why It Matters

This order illustrates how N.D. Cal. patent judges police the line between permissible early-stage infringement theories and impermissible claim-language parroting. It gives patentees concrete notice that "necessarily performs" formulations and result-oriented descriptions will not substitute for contentions identifying the accused structures and operations.

The ruling also shows proportionate case management: rather than imposing the severe sanction of striking contentions, the court required targeted amendments on a set deadline, with room for the parties to adjust it by agreement.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top