Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Pangea Legal Services submitted FOIA requests to DHS and ICE on September 22, 2025, and to CBP on October 24, 2025, seeking guidance, policies, directives, training, and communications about arrest and detention operations in the San Francisco Area of Responsibility and the Bay Area from November 1, 2024 onward, including records about enforcement targets or quotas. After no final response, Pangea sued on January 12, 2026.
The agencies agreed to monthly productions but disputed volume: Pangea attacked their 500–750-page monthly caps as contrary to FOIA's prompt-availability duty and questioned the factual support, while the agencies said Pangea's requested 3,000 pages per month exceeded their capabilities. On October 22, 2026, the court ordered each agency to submit a declaration from its most knowledgeable e-discovery personnel, corroborated by documents, explaining why it could not process more.
All discovery matters were referred to Magistrate Judge Peter H. Kang, who resolved the joint discovery letter brief without oral argument under Civil Local Rule 7-1(b).
The Court’s Holding
The court noted that all three agencies use first-in-first-out processing and that their declarations stated acceleration could potentially require diverting staff and resources from other requests, but reasoned that under FIFO the aging requests should naturally gain priority and resources. It also noted all three declarants admitted rates could increase and said they would endeavor to process faster.
The court faulted the declarations for calling the requests "complex" without identifying any standards or criteria or justifying a slower rate. It ordered each department to process 1,000 documents per month in December 2026–January 2027, 1,500 in February–March 2027, and 2,000 in April–May 2027, citing comparable FOIA processing-rate orders.
Pangea's motion to increase the processing rate was granted in part, and the parties must file joint status reports on February 5, April 2, and June 4, 2027. The order resolves Dkts. 30 and 34.
Key Takeaways
- A resisting agency must support discovery limits with specific facts, not boilerplate or conclusory labels such as "complex."
- An agency's own first-in-first-out procedures can undercut a claim that an aging FOIA request must remain at a flat "typical" processing rate.
- Courts may impose graduated processing schedules and periodic joint status reports to manage large FOIA productions proportionally.
Why It Matters
This order shows how proportionality review in FOIA discovery can force agencies to substantiate processing caps and can translate their own queue-management policies into concrete acceleration obligations.
The graduated 1,000-to-1,500-to-2,000-document schedule, paired with three reporting deadlines, offers a practical template for supervising disputed agency production capacity without accepting either side's proposed rate.