California Case Summaries

People v. Schultz — Court of Appeal affirms DUI convictions as amended but remands to itemize penalty assessments in minute order and abstract of judgment

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
People v. Schultz
Court
5th District Court of Appeal
Judge
Hill; DeSantos; Sandhu
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
F089167
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
prosecutorial misconduct, driving under the influence, field sobriety tests, consciousness of guilt, burden shifting, sentencing enhancements, Penal Code section 1385, great bodily injury, abstract of judgment, penalty assessments

Background

A Kern County jury convicted Marian P. Schultz of driving under the influence causing bodily injury and driving with a blood-alcohol content of 0.08 percent or more after his truck struck a motorcycle and a car while performing "doughnuts" in an intersection. Motorcyclist Armandeep Singh suffered catastrophic injuries. The jury found true great bodily injury and multiple-victim allegations. The trial court sentenced Schultz on count one to six years four months in prison—a 16-month base term plus a five-year enhancement under Penal Code section 12022.7, subdivision (b), and a stayed three-year enhancement under subdivision (a)—while striking punishment for a one-year enhancement under Vehicle Code section 23558 and staying count two under section 654.

Schultz appealed, arguing the prosecutor committed closing misconduct by framing his refusal to perform field sobriety tests as consciousness of guilt and by shifting the burden of proof regarding breath-device calibration. He also argued the trial court abused its sentencing discretion under Penal Code section 1385, subdivision (c), by declining to dismiss his great bodily injury enhancements based on post-trial competency proceedings and multiple enhancements.

The Court’s Holding

The Court of Appeal affirmed the judgment as amended with directions on limited remand. The court held the prosecutor did not misstate the law by arguing that Schultz's refusal to perform standard field sobriety tests showed consciousness of guilt. Unlike preliminary alcohol screening tests subject to a statutory right of refusal under Vehicle Code section 23612, standard field sobriety tests carry no statutory right to refuse, making refusal admissible. Additionally, commenting on the defense's failure to call an expert did not shift the burden of proof, and any presumed misconduct was harmless given the court's curative instructions and overwhelming evidence of guilt.

On sentencing, the court held Schultz forfeited his claims under Penal Code section 1385, subdivision (c), by not raising them below. On the merits, the trial court did not abuse its discretion: post-trial competency reports did not establish that a DSM-defined mental illness contributed to the 2019 crash, and aggravating factors neutralized the multiple-enhancement mitigating circumstance. Because the $1,209 penalty assessment was omitted from the minutes and abstract of judgment, the court remanded to amend both documents and affirmed the judgment as amended.

Key Takeaways

  • A prosecutor may argue that a driver's refusal to perform standard field sobriety tests shows consciousness of guilt, as those tests carry no statutory right of refusal.
  • Commenting on the defense's failure to present logical witnesses or expert testimony does not constitute impermissible burden shifting.
  • Prompt jury admonitions, correct burden instructions, and overwhelming evidence of intoxication render any passing prosecutorial misconduct harmless.
  • Enhancement-dismissal claims under Penal Code section 1385, subdivision (c), are forfeited if not raised at sentencing, and the mental illness mitigating circumstance requires a nexus between a DSM disorder and the crime.
  • Penalty assessments must be itemized by amount and statutory basis in both the sentencing minute order and the abstract of judgment.

Why It Matters

This decision clarifies that standard field sobriety tests lack statutory refusal protections, permitting consciousness-of-guilt arguments in California DUI trials. It also illustrates that competency evaluations do not satisfy the nexus requirement to dismiss enhancements for mental illness under Penal Code section 1385, while enforcing strict itemization of penalty assessments.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top