California Case Summaries

Lee T. v. K.M. — Trial Court Erred in Disallowing Evidence on Child Abuse Allegations and Applying Changed Circumstances Test to Educational Tiebreaking Request

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Lee T. v. K.M.
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Delgado; Adams (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Hanasono
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
B354762
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
child custody modification, tiebreaking authority, right to present evidence, offer of proof, best interest of the child, changed circumstances test

Background

Lee T. (mother) and K.M. (father) share a minor child diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder who receives specialized educational and therapeutic services. Although the parents shared joint legal and physical custody, earlier temporary custody carveouts granting mother educational tiebreaking authority expired in October 2024. In mid-2025, father filed requests for order (RFOs) seeking sole legal and physical custody based on allegations of child abuse by mother, as well as a separate request seeking tiebreaking authority over school placement decisions.

Mother opposed the requests, denied abuse, and sought renewed tiebreaking authority for herself. At a February 2026 evidentiary hearing where father was self-represented, the trial court repeatedly interrupted father's questioning of witnesses, asked its own questions, excused witnesses before father finished, and refused father's request to make an offer of proof under Evidence Code section 354. Although the court possessed father's proposed documentary exhibits, it never explicitly ruled on them. The trial court denied father's custody and tiebreaking requests for failure to show a significant change in circumstances, granted mother open-ended tiebreaking authority over school choice, and permitted each parent to select extracurricular activities on their own custodial time.

The Court’s Holding

The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Three, reversed the post-judgment order and remanded for a new hearing. The court held that denying father a meaningful opportunity to elicit witness testimony and refusing an offer of proof regarding child abuse allegations constituted a due process violation and reversible error per se under In re Marriage of Carlsson. Because the trial court curtailed witness examination and barred an offer of proof—making it difficult for father to demonstrate prejudice on appeal—the error infected the trial process and was not subject to harmless error review.

The appellate court separately held that the trial court applied an erroneous legal standard to the requests for educational tiebreaking authority. Where parents share joint legal custody, a request to add a tiebreaking carveout does not alter the underlying legal custody designation, meaning the changed circumstances rule does not apply. In the absence of a final judicial custody determination, the tiebreaking request was governed strictly by the best interests of the child standard. Finally, the court denied father's request to reassign the case to a different judicial officer on remand under Code of Civil Procedure section 170.1, finding the trial judge's commentary did not warrant disqualification.

Key Takeaways

  • A family court's inherent authority to manage courtroom efficiency cannot override a litigant's due process right to examine witnesses and present evidence regarding child abuse allegations.
  • Refusing to permit a party to complete witness examination or tender an offer of proof under Evidence Code section 354 constitutes reversible error per se.
  • A request by parents sharing joint legal custody to allocate tiebreaking authority over school choice does not effectuate a change in legal custody.
  • Unless a final judicial custody determination is established, requests to modify legal custody carveouts must be evaluated under the best interests of the child standard rather than the changed circumstances rule.
  • Disqualification and reassignment of a trial judge on remand under Code of Civil Procedure section 170.1 is an extraordinary remedy that will not be granted absent an affirmative showing of bias.

Why It Matters

This decision establishes firm procedural boundaries for family law trial courts managing heavy dockets, confirming that calendar efficiency cannot eclipse fundamental due process protections when child welfare and abuse allegations are raised. Litigants must be afforded a full opportunity to develop the evidentiary record, examine witnesses, and present offers of proof.

The ruling also clarifies the application of the changed circumstances doctrine under California family law, affirming that disputes over specific decision-making carveouts between parents sharing joint legal custody remain governed directly by the flexible best interests standard rather than the heightened changed circumstances requirement.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top