Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Victoria Lee Gomes sought judicial review of a final decision of the Commissioner of Social Security denying her application for disability benefits under the Social Security Act. On February 18, 2025, the district court remanded the action to the Commissioner for further proceedings pursuant to a voluntary stipulation, and judgment was entered in Plaintiff's favor. On remand, Plaintiff received an award of past-due disability benefits totaling $81,246.10.
Following the favorable administrative award, Plaintiff's counsel filed a motion under 42 U.S.C. § 406(b) seeking $11,112.23 in attorney's fees pursuant to a contingency fee agreement. That requested amount represented 13.7% of the retroactive benefit award, while Plaintiff's administrative representative had previously been awarded $9,200, bringing the combined total to $20,312.23, or 25% of the total past-due benefits. The Commissioner filed a response stating he neither supported nor opposed the motion and identified no basis to object.
The Court’s Holding
The district court granted the fee motion, concluding that the requested fee of $11,112.23 was reasonable under the standards established in Gisbrecht v. Barnhart and Crawford v. Astrue. Evaluating the character of representation and results obtained, the court observed that counsel achieved full success without dilatory conduct or substandard performance, warranting respect for the lawful contingent-fee contract within the 25% statutory ceiling.
The court further determined that counsel's expenditure of 20.6 attorney hours and 28.2 paralegal hours was reasonable given the 2,000-page administrative record and a substantial 38-page opening brief. The resulting effective hourly rate of $539 per attorney hour was well within and lower than typical rates recently approved across the district. Finally, because no prior fees were awarded under the Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA), the court held that no statutory offset was required.
Key Takeaways
- Contingent attorney fee awards under 42 U.S.C. § 406(b) are evaluated by looking first to the contingent fee agreement and testing it for reasonableness within the 25% statutory ceiling.
- An effective hourly rate of $539 per hour falls comfortably within approved ranges for Social Security disability representations in the Eastern District of California.
- Where an attorney receives no prior fee award under the Equal Access to Justice Act, the § 406(b) past-due benefit award is not subject to an EAJA offset.
Why It Matters
The decision confirms the district court's deferential approach to lawful contingent-fee arrangements in Social Security appeals when counsel assumes full risk of non-recovery and achieves favorable past-due benefit awards on remand.
It also illustrates that fees awarded to non-attorney administrative representatives at the agency level are factored into the overall 25% statutory cap on past-due benefit deductions under § 406(b).