California Case Summaries

Jada A. Yee v. Commissioner of Social Security — Remanding Denial of Disability Benefits Where Administrative Law Judge Improperly Relied on Isolated Reports of Mental Health Improvement to Discount Treating Nurse Practitioner’s Opinions

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Jada A. Yee v. Commissioner of Social Security
Court
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Judge
Chi Soo Kim (District Judges of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California, 2024)
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
2:25-cv-03153
Status
Unreported
Topics
Social Security Disability, Administrative Law, Mental Health Impairments, Treating Provider Opinion, Residual Functional Capacity

Background

Plaintiff Jada A. Yee applied for disability insurance benefits and supplemental security income under Titles II and XVI of the Social Security Act in July 2021, alleging disability beginning January 1, 2020, due to Bipolar 1 Disorder, depression, anxiety, and obsessive-compulsive disorder/dermatillomania. Following an initial administrative denial and a stipulated voluntary remand in prior district court litigation, an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) held a second hearing in May 2025 and issued a decision in July 2025 finding Yee not disabled at step five.

In determining Yee's residual functional capacity, the ALJ found she could perform work at all exertional levels subject to nonexertional limitations to simple job instructions, occasional routine changes, occasional interaction with coworkers and supervisors without teamwork, no public contact, and no production-rate pace. The ALJ credited opinions from state agency consultants and a consultative psychologist but partially discounted October 2020 and September 2021 opinions from treating Nurse Practitioner Murphy that Yee had poor ability to complete normal workweeks without interruptions and was unlikely to work 40 hours weekly.

Yee filed this action for judicial review under 42 U.S.C. § 405(g), asserting that the ALJ erred in evaluating the medical opinion evidence and in discounting her subjective symptom testimony. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment before United States Magistrate Judge Chi Soo Kim, proceeding on full consent under 28 U.S.C. § 636(c) and Local Rule 302(c)(15).

The Court’s Holding

The court granted Yee's motion for summary judgment, denied the Commissioner's cross-motion, reversed the administrative decision, and remanded for further proceedings. The court held that the ALJ erred in discounting Nurse Practitioner Murphy's opinions on the ground that Yee improved with medication, reduced sedative use, and therapy, because the ALJ cited treatment records generally without specificity and relied on isolated instances of improvement from a fluctuating record.

Applying Ninth Circuit precedent, the court emphasized that mental health symptoms inherently wax and wane and that reports of improvement must be viewed in the context of the claimant's overall well-being. The longitudinal record demonstrated that Yee continued to experience severe skin-picking, self-medication, cutting, and suicidal ideation requiring safety planning, precluding the ALJ from treating isolated periods of positive medication response as substantial evidence of sustained improvement.

Although Yee requested a direct remand for an award of benefits under the credit-as-true rule, the court declined to award benefits outright. Because the record as a whole created serious doubt as to whether Yee was disabled during the relevant period, the court exercised its discretion to remand for further administrative proceedings, directing the ALJ to adequately analyze Murphy's opinions while leaving the ultimate weighing of evidence to the agency.

Key Takeaways

  • An ALJ may not discount a treating medical provider's restrictive mental health opinion by cherry-picking isolated reports of improvement from a record showing persistent waxing and waning of psychiatric symptoms.
  • Under 20 C.F.R. § 416.920c, an ALJ must articulate a coherent explanation supported by substantial evidence when assessing the supportability and consistency of medical source opinions.
  • Even when an ALJ commits reversible legal error in evaluating medical opinions, a district court retains discretion to remand for further proceedings rather than awarding benefits if the record leaves serious doubt regarding disability.

Why It Matters

This decision reinforces established Ninth Circuit authority prohibiting administrative adjudicators from treating temporary symptomatic lulls in mental illness as substantial evidence of sustained capacity for competitive work.

The ruling also underscores the rigorous standard for securing an immediate award of benefits under the credit-as-true doctrine, reaffirming that enduring ambiguities in the longitudinal disability record require remand for administrative reevaluation.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top