California Case Summaries

Spazz, Inc. v. Gursey Schneider LLP — Triable Issues of Fact Preclude Summary Judgment on Accounting Firm’s Vicarious Liability for Employee’s Failure to File Client Taxes

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Spazz, Inc. v. Gursey Schneider LLP
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Baker; Hoffstadt (Jerry Brown, 2014); Kim (D.) (Jerry Brown, 2018)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
B342475
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
respondeat superior, vicarious liability, scope of employment, summary judgment, accounting malpractice, fraudulent concealment

Background

Plaintiffs Spazz, Inc., Slang East/West, LLC, Metallica guitarist Robert Trujillo, and his wife Chloe Trujillo sued accounting firm Gursey Schneider LLP and its employee, Stacey Summers, after Summers failed to file plaintiffs' tax returns for several years, leading to substantial tax penalties and interest. Summers, a certified public accountant and Tax Director at Gursey, had handled plaintiffs' taxes since before joining Gursey under an oral flat-fee arrangement. After joining the firm, Summers repeatedly met with Robert Trujillo at Gursey's offices, corresponded via her firm email account, and prepared returns using firm computers with Gursey identified on some forms.

Gursey argued that it could not be held vicariously liable under respondeat superior because plaintiffs were Summers's personal clients who never signed an engagement letter, never paid Gursey directly, and were never entered into the firm's client billing system. Plaintiffs filed a cross-motion for summary adjudication seeking a determination that Gursey was vicariously liable as a matter of law. The Los Angeles County Superior Court granted summary judgment in favor of Gursey and denied plaintiffs' motion for summary adjudication, concluding Summers acted outside the scope of her employment as a matter of law.

The Court’s Holding

The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Five, reversed the summary judgment in favor of Gursey and affirmed the denial of plaintiffs' motion for summary adjudication. Applying California's broad respondeat superior framework and the foreseeability test, the appellate panel held that a reasonable factfinder could find a sufficient causal nexus between Summers's alleged misconduct and her employment as a CPA at Gursey.

The court reasoned that Summers performed the exact type of accounting work she was hired to provide, utilized firm email and computer infrastructure, conducted client meetings in Gursey's conference rooms during business hours, and prepared returns listing Gursey's name. The risk that an accounting firm's CPA might prepare returns without routing the client through formal administrative onboarding is broadly incidental and inherent to operating an accounting practice. However, conflicting evidence—including the preexisting personal relationship, lack of formal engagement, absence of direct payments to Gursey, and Summers's conflicting testimony—precluded summary adjudication for plaintiffs as well, necessitating a trial.

Key Takeaways

  • An employer may face vicarious liability under respondeat superior even if an employee violates firm onboarding procedures and the employer receives no financial compensation for the services.
  • Under California law, whether professional services rendered on an employer's premises and systems fall within the scope of employment is generally a question of fact unless the undisputed evidence permits only one inference.
  • The risk of a professional performing unauthorized or improperly onboarded client work using firm facilities is a foreseeable risk inherent to the operation of a professional services firm.
  • Dueling motions for summary judgment on respondeat superior must both be denied when the evidentiary record reveals conflicting inferences regarding whether the conduct was purely personal or within the scope of employment.

Why It Matters

This decision underscores the stringent evidentiary hurdle employers face when attempting to defeat vicarious liability on summary judgment based on internal administrative rules or missing formal engagement agreements. It clarifies that California's foreseeability test under respondeat superior looks broadly to whether the enterprise created the risk and opportunity for the professional conduct, rather than whether management specifically authorized the representation.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top