Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Ni He, a Chinese citizen and immigration detainee represented by counsel, filed this 28 U.S.C. § 2241 petition alleging ICE violated the Fifth Amendment by arresting her at a scheduled USCIS biometrics appointment on August 11, 2026 without advance notice or an opportunity to respond. Respondents argued the petition was an abuse of the writ because she had filed a habeas petition in He v. Mullin just over two months earlier; Petitioner responded that missing government records, including a Form I-213, excused omitting the claim.
The court found the claim arose a month before the first petition and its essential facts were within Petitioner's own knowledge. It accepted that neither Petitioner nor former counsel received the Form I-213, but held the later-produced record merely corroborated facts she already knew from the date of arrest.
The Court’s Holding
Applying the common-law abuse-of-the-writ doctrine to § 2241 immigration detention petitions, the court held Respondents adequately pleaded abuse and that Petitioner had a full and fair opportunity to raise the pre-arrest claim in her first petition. Under Eldridge, a claim is barred if it could have been raised, and unlike decisions postdating an earlier petition, the August 11 arrest predated the first filing.
The court found no cause: the missing Form I-213 was not needed to allege the claim, ordinary attorney error and limited English do not establish cause under McCleskey, and the legal basis was reasonably available before the first petition. It also found no fundamental miscarriage of justice, assuming without deciding that an extraordinary showing could suffice, because Petitioner asserted a procedural violation and family hardship rather than legal ineligibility for detention.
The court did not reach exhaustion or the merits and expressly stated the order does not find that the arrest complied with due process. It dismissed the sole claim without leave to amend; denied release, declaratory relief, a prohibition on renewed detention, a compliance report, and further production of records; denied as moot only Petitioner's request to bar her transfer from the Adelanto ICE Processing Center during the pendency of this action; dismissed the action as to all Respondents; and directed entry of judgment.
Key Takeaways
- A § 2241 immigration detainee's second petition is barred as an abuse of the writ when the claim arose before the first petition and the petitioner knew its essential facts at that time.
- A government record obtained later does not establish cause under McCleskey when it merely corroborates facts the petitioner already knew and the claim can be pleaded without it.
- Attorney error short of ineffective assistance, reliance on prior counsel, and limited English do not establish cause, and there is no constitutional right to counsel in federal habeas proceedings.
- An asserted procedural violation plus family hardship does not establish a fundamental miscarriage of justice, or the exception would swallow the rule.
- A dismissal for abuse of the writ is not a merits ruling that the arrest complied with due process and does not foreclose properly exhausted claims or claims arising from later events.
Why It Matters
The decision applies McCleskey and Eldridge to a successive immigration habeas petition challenging the manner of arrest, reinforcing that later-discovered corroboration does not excuse an omitted claim whose factual basis was already available.
The court distinguished recent district decisions excusing similar omissions and left open the precise standard for fundamental miscarriage of justice in civil immigration detention cases while declining to reach exhaustion or the merits.