Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
The parties stipulated to a protective order because discovery was expected to include protected health information, personally identifiable information, customer and pricing lists, and confidential commercial, financial, technical, and proprietary information belonging to the parties and to Agiliti Health, Inc.’s non-party employees.
The order limits confidentiality to material qualifying under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(c), prohibits mass or tactical designations, and requires designation before production, with a 30-day period after receipt of a deposition transcript to designate testimony.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Pedro V. Castillo found good cause and entered the stipulated order, allowing designated material to be used only for prosecuting, defending, or settling this action and disclosed only to listed recipients, including counsel, necessary party personnel, experts and vendors who sign the required acknowledgment, the court, court reporters, deposition witnesses under stated conditions, and agreed mediators.
The order places the burden of persuasion on the designating party when a designation is challenged, requires Local Rule 37.1 dispute resolution, and preserves continued protection until the court rules. It also addresses subpoenas from other litigation and non-party confidential information, requires notice and cooperation, and bars production while a timely protective-order request is pending.
Key Takeaways
- Confidentiality designations must be limited to material that qualifies for protection; indiscriminate or improper designations may expose the designating party to sanctions.
- A challenge to a designation does not suspend protection: the material remains protected at the designated level until the court resolves the dispute, and the designating party bears the persuasion burden.
- The protective order does not itself authorize sealing. Any under-seal filing must satisfy Civil Local Rule 79-5 and obtain an order for the specific material; if sealing is denied, the receiving party may file publicly unless the court directs otherwise.
- At trial, previously designated court-filed information becomes presumptively public unless the trial judge makes specific factual findings supporting compelling reasons for continued protection, and the order does not govern trial use.
- After final disposition, protected material must be returned or destroyed within 60 days of a written request, subject to counsel’s right to retain archival copies that remain subject to the order.
Why It Matters
This is a discovery-management ruling rather than a merits decision. It facilitates exchange of sensitive health, personal, and business information while expressly rejecting blanket sealing and preserving the higher public-access standard for merits material and trial use.
The order also incorporates Rule 26(b)(5)(B) procedures for inadvertently produced privileged material and permits the parties to incorporate any Rule 502(d) or (e) agreement, leaving privilege-waiver consequences to a later agreement or separate order.