Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
In two related actions, Magistrate Judge Hixson issued a Discovery Order and Report and Recommendation addressing discovery violations by defendant Fathi Abdulrahim Harara and awarding $59,000 in sanctions to plaintiff Michael Radice. All parties sought relief under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 72(a) and Civil Local Rule 72-2, and the district court resolved the objections without oral argument.
Judge Hixson had reduced the requested fees from $166,500.50 to about $118,000 by deducting time spent on work preceding the discovery violations, then cut that figure in half because roughly half of the fees incurred during the violation period would have been incurred anyway or reflected excessive work. Radice separately sought terminating sanctions and submitted a supplemental declaration claiming an additional $71,951.50 in fees.
The Court’s Holding
The district court adopted Judge Hixson's recommendation and order in full except as to the sanctions amount and payment deadline. It found the fee calculation should exclude all billing predating the first discovery violation on April 18, 2026, yielding roughly $101,000 rather than $118,000; halving that figure produced sanctions of $50,500 instead of $59,000.
The court extended Harara's payment deadline to January 15, 2027, or 14 days after the next Case Management Conference, whichever was later, and denied Radice's motion for terminating sanctions for the reasons stated in the Discovery Order. All other objections by Radice, the United States, and Harara were denied. The court also requested random reassignment to another district judge because the undersigned judge would be unavailable in 2027, and noted the parties had not definitively waived a jury trial.
Key Takeaways
- Under Rule 72(a), a district court defers to a magistrate judge's non-dispositive discovery order unless it is clearly erroneous or contrary to law, and here the reviewing court endorsed the magistrate judge's fee-reduction methodology while correcting the arithmetic.
- Discovery sanctions under Rule 37(b)(2)(C) must be limited to reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees, so fees for work predating the violations or work that was excessive or unnecessary may be excluded.
- A supplemental fee declaration does not automatically warrant increasing sanctions; the amount remains committed to the trial court's discretion.
- A judge's unavailability in a future year can prompt a request for random reassignment even where the case is trial-ready, and the successor judge may adjust the sanctions payment deadline.
Why It Matters
This order illustrates how district courts review magistrate judges' discovery sanctions awards under the clearly erroneous or contrary to law standard, while still recalculating the dollar figure when the underlying fee record supports a different cutoff date.
The court's comments on jury-trial waiver leave that issue open for the reassigned judge, signaling that a party's stated willingness to try claims to a jury and prior counsel's agreement to a bench trial did not conclusively resolve the right.