Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Self-represented state prisoner Daronta T. Lewis filed a civil rights complaint under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 seeking damages, along with a motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis (IFP). The court reviewed his prior prisoner actions and identified six earlier dismissals under the Prison Litigation Reform Act's three-strikes provision, 28 U.S.C. § 1915(g).
The court catalogued prior dismissals including a duplicative action Lewis admitted filing intentionally (Ugwueze), suits dismissed for failure to state a cognizable claim or name a proper defendant (Allio, Hoagland), and complaints dismissed as prolix, vague, and conclusory in violation of Rule 8(a) with no corrective amendment filed (Brown, Antonen, Neilson). Following Andrews v. King, the court evaluated each dismissal order and concluded each counts as a strike.
The Court’s Holding
The court found that Lewis had accumulated at least three qualifying strikes under § 1915(g), and that the court itself would have to review under § 1915(g) all future actions Lewis files while incarcerated and in which he seeks IFP status. Rather than dismissing immediately, the court followed Andrews by giving Lewis notice and an opportunity to be heard.
The court ordered Lewis to show cause in writing within 28 days why his IFP motion should not be denied and the action dismissed under § 1915(g), or alternatively to pay the full $405 filing fee within the same period. Only after a timely response or payment will the court conduct initial review of the complaint and address pending motions.
Key Takeaways
- A duplicative prisoner complaint intentionally filed can count as a PLRA strike because it is frivolous or malicious, consistent with Cato v. United States and LeBlanc v. Asuncion.
- Failure to assert a cognizable claim, failure to name a proper defendant, and failure to amend after leave to amend can each independently qualify as strikes under § 1915(g).
- Repeated Rule 8(a) violations after an opportunity to cure constitute failures to state a claim and count as strikes under Knapp v. Hogan.
- A magistrate judge's dismissal without prejudice can still count as a strike even before defendant consent to magistrate jurisdiction, per Hoffmann v. Pulido.
- Denial of IFP status under § 1915(g) does not bar the prisoner from pursuing claims if the full filing fee is paid at the outset.
Why It Matters
This order illustrates the screening process courts use before applying the PLRA three-strikes bar: the court must identify specific qualifying prior dismissals, notify the prisoner, and allow a response before denying IFP status or dismissing. It also confirms that multiple distinct pleading deficiencies—duplicative filing, failure to state a claim, improper defendant, and persistent Rule 8 violations—can each supply strikes.
The order leaves the merits of Lewis's § 1983 complaint entirely unreviewed; initial review is deferred until the show-cause response or fee payment. Failure to respond or pay may result in dismissal for failure to prosecute.