Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Apple, a defendant in a patent infringement case originally filed in the Eastern District of Texas and now pending in the Southern District of California, subpoenaed nonparty Tangible IP to produce a corporate representative for a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition. Apple believed Tangible's principal, Louis Carbonneau, held information relevant to patent purchase and licensing issues central to the underlying litigation.
After conferring over an alleged facial defect, Apple amended the subpoena on July 24, 2026. Tangible objected on multiple grounds and refused to make Carbonneau available. Apple moved to compel on July 31, 2026, the day fact discovery closed in the underlying case. Tangible argued the motion was untimely.
The Court’s Holding
Because the issuing court in Texas no longer had the case, the Court treated the Southern District of California as the court where the action was pending for Rule 45(f) purposes. Although neither party requested transfer and Tangible did not consent, the Court found exceptional circumstances: discovery had closed, the dispositive-motions cutoff had passed, the parties had jointly sought deadline extensions, and the California court was already adjudicating other discovery disputes in the underlying case.
The Court concluded that timeliness, relevance, burden, and cumulativeness objections depended on the California court's schedule and the existing discovery record, so deciding the motion locally risked disrupting that court's management of the litigation. The Court transferred the motion without expressing any view on the merits of Apple's motion or Tangible's objections.
Key Takeaways
- Rule 45(f) permits transfer to the court where the underlying action is pending even when the issuing court no longer has the case and the subpoenaed nonparty does not consent, if exceptional circumstances outweigh the nonparty's interest in local resolution.
- Pending related discovery disputes and closed discovery schedules in the transferee court can constitute exceptional circumstances because local resolution risks disrupting that court's management of the litigation.
- A transfer under Rule 45(f) does not decide the merits of the motion to compel or the nonparty's objections; those issues remain for the transferee court.
Why It Matters
This order illustrates how courts apply Rule 45(f) flexibly when the original issuing court loses the underlying case, routing subpoena disputes to the court now managing the litigation rather than resolving them locally.
The decision also underscores that nonparty interests in local resolution are weighed against the practical needs of coordinated discovery management in complex patent litigation spanning multiple districts.