Reported / Citable
Background
A.M.A.S., an Egyptian national and lawful permanent resident of the United States, was granted deferral of removal under the Convention Against Torture after an immigration judge found he faced torture in Egypt. The government did not appeal. On April 28, 2026, the government removed him instead to Equatorial Guinea under a third-country arrangement, giving short notice and denying his request for a reasonable-fear interview.
As detailed in the dissent, Equatorial Guinean authorities held A.M.A.S. under armed guard, where he suffered beatings, death threats, and incommunicado detention. On September 15, 2026, he filed suit in the District of Arizona, alleging that third-country removal without notice or an opportunity to assert fear violated Fifth Amendment procedural due process and the Administrative Procedure Act.
On October 6, 2026, the district court ruled solely on the constitutional claim, holding the removal procedure unconstitutional and ordering the government to facilitate his return under Noem v. Abrego Garcia. After the court issued further implementation orders, the government appealed, and a motions panel referred its emergency stay request to the merits panel.
The Court’s Holding
In a per curiam order, Judges Graber, Bennett, and H.A. Thomas granted the government's emergency motion for a stay pending appeal in full. The order recited the four Nken stay factors and concluded without explanation that they supported issuing a stay.
Judge Graber dissented in large part. She concluded that the government failed to satisfy any stay factor and would have stayed only later orders micromanaging executive diplomacy, while leaving intact the core order requiring the government to facilitate A.M.A.S.'s return pending appeal.
Judge Graber emphasized that returning a single individual caused no irreparable harm, distinguishing the Supreme Court's stay in DHS v. D.V.D. as involving classwide APA vacatur of an entire program. She also found the government unlikely to succeed under binding circuit precedent in Ibarra-Perez v. United States, with equities strongly favoring relief from ongoing abuse.
Key Takeaways
- The Ninth Circuit granted an unexplained emergency stay pending appeal, halting district-court orders requiring the government to facilitate a deportee's return from Equatorial Guinea.
- Judge Graber dissented in large part, finding no irreparable harm to the government from returning a single individual, distinguishing the nationwide program vacatur in DHS v. D.V.D.
- The dissent would have stayed only post-judgment implementation orders that impinged on foreign affairs, while sustaining the core facilitation remedy approved in Noem v. Abrego Garcia.
- The dissent concluded binding circuit precedent in Ibarra-Perez v. United States foreclosed the government's likelihood of success on its jurisdictional challenge.
- The dissent highlighted that the district court awarded relief solely on an individualized procedural due process claim rather than classwide APA relief.
Why It Matters
The ruling illustrates the Ninth Circuit's grant of unelaborated emergency stays in high-stakes immigration cases, even over uncontested evidence of severe foreign detention and physical abuse, leaving the immediate enforceability of Abrego Garcia return orders unsettled.
Judge Graber's dissent establishes a framework for distinguishing Supreme Court emergency stays in classwide APA litigation from individualized due process challenges seeking return to dispute third-country removal destinations.