California Case Summaries

Degueros-Mota v. Blanche — Ninth Circuit rejects challenges to reinstatement of prior removal order and finds no due process prejudice

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Degueros-Mota v. Blanche
Court
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
Judge
S.R. Thomas (Bill Clinton, 1996); Friedland (Barack Obama, 2014); Bress (Donald Trump, 2019)
Date Decided
2026-11-20
Docket No.
25-2769
Status
Unreported
Topics
immigration, reinstatement of removal order, unlawful reentry, due process, prejudice requirement, administrative record review

Background

Angel Didier Degueros-Mota petitioned for review of a Department of Homeland Security order reinstating his prior removal order under 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(5). The Ninth Circuit panel (S.R. Thomas, Friedland, and Bress) noted that the parties were familiar with the facts and history and did not recount them. The court confirmed jurisdiction under 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(1) and applied de novo review to legal questions and substantial-evidence review to factual findings, with review limited to the administrative record and confirmation of the agency's compliance with reinstatement regulations.

Degueros-Mota raised several challenges: that DHS failed to comply with 8 C.F.R. § 241.8(a)(1) regarding the prior removal order; that DHS unreasonably determined he unlawfully reentered under § 241.8(a)(3) without specifying the manner of reentry; that being "waved through" by a border agent meant he did not unlawfully reenter; and that procedural defects — including his pending criminal illegal-reentry charge, DHS's failure to consider the charge's later dismissal, and his removal to Mexico after filing a petition for review — violated due process.

The Court’s Holding

On the prior-order element, the court held that § 241.8(a)(1) requires only a narrow and mechanical determination that the person is an alien subject to a prior order. The record showed DHS had the prior removal order on file, and a records search after apprehension revealed a January 19, 2005 removal order and a January 20, 2005 removal. Substantial evidence therefore supported DHS's finding.

On unlawful reentry, the court held that § 241.8(a)(3) likewise requires only a narrow and mechanical determination and does not require specifying the manner of reentry. Degueros-Mota did not claim valid authorization at reentry, the record showed no waiver of inadmissibility between his January 2005 deportation and later reentry, and he provided no evidence of lawful reentry despite the opportunity. The court also held that precedent forecloses the argument that being "waved through" by a border agent defeats a finding of unlawful reentry.

On due process, the court held that a noncitizen must show prejudice by presenting plausible scenarios in which a more elaborate process would have changed the outcome. Degueros-Mota did not explain how his criminal case status or premature removal affected the reinstatement proceedings, identified no evidence he would have presented to show lawful reentry, and made no allegation that he could credibly have challenged the factual predicates for reinstatement absent the alleged errors. The due process claim failed for lack of prejudice, and the petition for review was denied.

Key Takeaways

  • Reinstatement under 8 C.F.R. § 241.8 requires only narrow, mechanical determinations of prior removal order and unlawful reentry, not detailed findings on the manner of reentry.
  • A petitioner's claim of being "waved through" by a border agent does not establish lawful reentry under controlling Ninth Circuit precedent.
  • A due process challenge to reinstatement proceedings requires a showing of prejudice through plausible alternative outcomes; unsupported assertions of procedural error are insufficient.
  • The court's review of a reinstatement order is confined to the administrative record and confirmation of regulatory compliance.
  • The panel denied the motion to stay removal and denied the motions for injunctive relief and to supplement the record as moot.

Why It Matters

This unpublished memorandum reinforces the limited judicial role in reviewing reinstatement orders and the narrow scope of the agency's required determinations under 8 C.F.R. § 241.8. It confirms that challenges to the manner of reentry or to a border agent's discretionary allowance do not overcome the mechanical reinstatement framework.

The decision also illustrates the practical consequence of the prejudice requirement in immigration due process claims: petitioners must connect alleged procedural errors to concrete potential differences in outcome, including identifying evidence or grounds for relief that the errors foreclosed.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top