California Case Summaries

Dos Santos v. Blanche — Ninth Circuit denies petition challenging BIA affirmance of asylum, withholding, and CAT denials

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Dos Santos v. Blanche
Court
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
Judge
McKEOWN (Bill Clinton, 1998); W. Fletcher (William J. Clinton, 1998); DESAI (Joe Biden, 2022)
Date Decided
2026-11-20
Docket No.
25-7027
Status
Unreported
Topics
immigration, asylum, withholding of removal, Convention Against Torture, substantial evidence, past persecution, future persecution, record development, stay of removal

Background

Liliana Dos Santos and her minor child M.L.D.S. petitioned for review of a Board of Immigration Appeals order affirming the immigration judge's denial of their claims for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture. The BIA affirmed without opinion, so the Ninth Circuit reviewed the immigration judge's decision directly.

The immigration judge found Dos Santos testified credibly, and the court therefore accepted her testimony as true while reviewing factual findings under the deferential substantial evidence standard. Dos Santos testified that a member of her church in Angola confronted her and threatened to kill her because her father is Congolese.

Petitioners argued the immigration judge improperly considered the passage of time and family members' status, failed to consider all protected grounds, and failed to develop the record despite their pro se status. They also sought a stay of removal.

The Court’s Holding

Substantial evidence did not compel a finding of past persecution: although credible death threats can constitute persecution when sufficiently menacing, the record did not compel a finding that the isolated threat met that standard.

Substantial evidence also did not compel a finding of an objectively reasonable fear of future persecution. The lone threat was roughly twelve years old, there was no evidence the threatener retained any interest in Dos Santos, and numerous family members remained in Angola without reported harm since 2012, making the claimed fear too speculative under the governing standard.

The court rejected the record-development argument, finding the immigration judge elicited substantial credible testimony and petitioners identified no country-conditions evidence that would change the analysis. Substantial evidence supported denial of CAT protection because petitioners reported no problems with Angolan or Brazilian authorities and no evidence showed government-instigated, consented, or acquiesced torture. The petition was denied, the motion to stay removal denied, and the temporary stay lifted.

Key Takeaways

  • An isolated death threat, even if credible, does not compel a finding of past persecution unless it is so menacing as to cause significant actual suffering or harm.
  • Stale threats, lack of continuing interest by the threatener, and unharmed family members remaining in the home country can render a fear of future persecution too speculative.
  • A pro se petitioner's record-development claim fails where the immigration judge elicited substantial credible testimony and the petitioner identifies no missing evidence that would alter the outcome.
  • CAT protection requires a showing that torture would more likely than not occur by or with the acquiescence of the government; testimony of no problems with police or government undermines that showing.

Why It Matters

This unpublished memorandum illustrates the demanding substantial-evidence standard in asylum cases: even credible threats may fall short of persecution, and passage of time plus family members' uneventful presence can defeat an objectively reasonable future fear.

The decision also confirms that an immigration judge satisfies the duty to develop a pro se record by thorough questioning, particularly where the petitioner does not identify specific missing evidence that would change the result.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top