Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Luis Hector Acosta-Valenzuela, a native and citizen of Mexico, petitioned for review of a BIA decision dismissing his appeal from an Immigration Judge's denial of cancellation of removal under 8 U.S.C. § 1229b(b). The Ninth Circuit had jurisdiction under 8 U.S.C. § 1252 and reviewed the agency's findings for substantial evidence.
Cancellation of removal requires a showing of exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to qualifying U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident family members. The panel applied the demanding standard from Gonzalez-Juarez v. Bondi and In re Monreal-Aguinaga, under which the hardship must substantially exceed what ordinarily results from removal.
The Court’s Holding
The panel held that the BIA's hardship determination was supported by substantial evidence. Although petitioner had several minor children who relied on him for support, the agency considered the family's size and the children's ages, health, and circumstances, and the record showed no recent need for medical treatment and that the children's medical issues were well controlled.
The panel further reasoned that the IJ and BIA reasonably inferred, based on petitioner's welding experience and the family's prior receipt of food stamps, that petitioner could provide some support from Mexico and the family could reapply for food stamps. The children's mother remained in the United States and one adult son could contribute financially. On this record, petitioner did not meet the very demanding hardship standard, so the petition was denied.
The court also noted that the existing stay of removal would remain in place until the mandate issues.
Key Takeaways
- Exceptional and extremely unusual hardship must deviate in the extreme from the ordinary hardship of removal and is a very demanding standard.
- Substantial evidence supports a hardship finding where children's medical issues are well controlled and no recent treatment is needed.
- Reasonable inferences about a petitioner's ability to work and a family's eligibility for benefits can support denial of cancellation of removal.
- Family members remaining in the United States, including a contributing adult child, can mitigate hardship to qualifying relatives.
- A stay of removal remains in effect until the mandate issues.
Why It Matters
This unpublished memorandum illustrates how the Ninth Circuit applies substantial evidence review to BIA hardship findings in cancellation cases, emphasizing that ordinary financial and family consequences of removal generally do not satisfy the exceptional and extremely unusual hardship standard.
The disposition is not for publication and is not precedent except as provided by Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3.