Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
W.W. appeals from a judgment reappointing the Public Guardian of Los Angeles as her conservator under the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act. She contends insufficient evidence supports the trial court's finding that she is gravely disabled. The only witness who testified at her trial, a stipulated expert, relied exclusively upon statements in W.W.'s residential chart to form her opinions. Neither the chart, nor any statements made in the chart, were admitted into evidence.
At the November 2025 trial, forensic psychologist Marion Arom was the sole witness. W.W. refused to attend or speak with Arom, and after a hearsay objection was sustained, Arom said she had "only information from the chart" and "nothing else to testify from." The court permitted reliance on the chart so long as its contents were not disclosed, overruled further hearsay, foundation, and People v. Sanchez objections, denied appointed counsel's request to continue the matter to procure the chart's declarants, and credited Arom's opinion that W.W. remained gravely disabled.
The Public Guardian filed no respondent's brief and later sought relief from default more than two months after its brief was due. The Court of Appeal denied that application for lack of good cause and noted the proposed brief relied on unsworn statements from stand-in counsel and an unidentified facility employee, for which the Public Guardian supplied no admissibility authority.
The Court’s Holding
The court reviewed the LPS Act framework, including the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt grave-disability finding and the bar on admitting a conservatorship investigation report at a contested trial to the extent it contains inadmissible hearsay. Under People v. Sanchez, an expert may not relate case-specific out-of-court statements for their truth unless independently proven or covered by a hearsay exception, and an expert opinion based on assumptions of fact without evidentiary support has no evidentiary value.
Applying those principles, virtually no facts were admitted to support Arom's diagnoses or grave-disability opinion. The Public Guardian did not produce the residential chart or offer it as a business record or sufficiently reliable medical record, and the court denied a continuance to obtain the declarants. The opinion derived from the unadmitted notations therefore did not constitute substantial evidence, requiring reversal.
The court declined to address W.W.'s arguments under the 2023 medical-records hearsay exception in Welfare and Institutions Code section 5122 because the trial court never considered that exception. It also explained that reversal does not itself vacate any later reestablished conservatorship and does not bar a new reestablishment petition.
Key Takeaways
- An LPS expert opinion resting entirely on case-specific statements in a chart that was never admitted cannot supply substantial evidence of grave disability.
- Trial courts cannot avoid the hearsay problem by letting an expert rely on chart contents while barring disclosure of what the chart says when no hearsay exception or independent proof supports those contents.
- The section 5122 medical-records exception requires a preliminary reliability determination and was not at issue where the trial court never considered it.
- Reversal of a one-year reestablishment judgment does not disturb conservatorship status created by later proceedings and does not bar a fresh reestablishment petition.
Why It Matters
This unpublished decision applies Sanchez's limits on case-specific hearsay in the heightened-beyond-reasonable-doubt LPS context and treats an unsupported expert opinion as having no evidentiary value, reinforcing that efficiency shortcuts cannot replace admissible proof of grave disability.
The opinion also clarifies the limited practical effect of reversal where the challenged one-year judgment has expired or later reestablishment proceedings have occurred.