Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Tajinder Singh entered the United States near San Ysidro, California, in June 2018 and was placed in removal proceedings after a credible-fear finding. In September 2018, an Adelanto immigration judge released him on a stipulated $22,000 bond with appeal waived. Singh lived at liberty in the United States for over eight years, first in New York and later in Fresno, California, with no record of a bond breach, release violation, arrest, charge, or conviction. His removal proceedings were dismissed in September 2024 without a final removal order, and he received a work authorization card in October 2025 based on his asylum application pending since December 2018.
On November 7, 2026, Immigration and Customs Enforcement detained Singh at a gas station and held him at the Adelanto ICE Processing Center without a warrant, charging document, written reasons, notice, or hearing. He filed a 28 U.S.C. § 2241 habeas petition on November 10 and a temporary restraining order application on November 11. On November 12, he consented to magistrate judge jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 636(c), and the court issued a scheduling notice under General Order 26-05 requiring any consent withdrawal within 24 hours of service and an answer within seven days. Respondents filed nothing, leaving the petition unopposed.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Anna Y. Park granted the petition and ordered immediate release. Under Mathews v. Eldridge, the court held that Singh had a protected due process interest following his 2018 bond release and roughly eight years at liberty in the country. Under the party-presentation principle and Ninth Circuit precedent, Respondents' silence forfeited opposing arguments and left the record devoid of any government interest justifying detention. Because Singh's showing—including compliance with his release terms and no apparent risk of flight or danger—was uncontroverted, all Mathews factors favored relief without requiring the court to decide every aspect of his claims.
The court ordered Respondents to release Singh immediately under his pre-detention conditions, return all seized personal belongings—including identification, work authorization, and official documents—at release, and file a Notice of Release within three days confirming his release and the return of his belongings. It also enjoined re-arrest or re-detention absent strict statutory and constitutional compliance, including at least seven days' notice and a pre-deprivation hearing before a neutral factfinder where Singh may have counsel present and Respondents show by clear and convincing evidence that public-safety or appearance interests outweigh his liberty interest and no alternative mitigates flight risk. The temporary restraining order motion was denied as moot, and judgment was ordered for Singh.
Key Takeaways
- The government's failure to answer an expedited habeas petition forfeits opposing arguments under the party-presentation principle and leaves no record of a government interest supporting detention.
- A noncitizen living at liberty in the United States for years in compliance with an immigration bond holds a protected due process interest against summary re-detention.
- Release orders may require restoring prior conditions, returning seized identification and work-authorization documents, and filing a Notice of Release within three days.
- Courts may bar re-detention absent seven days' notice and a pre-deprivation hearing with counsel where clear and convincing evidence shows no alternative mitigates flight risk.
Why It Matters
This order shows how the Central District of California's General Order 26-05 accelerates immigration habeas cases through short deadlines for answers and magistrate-consent withdrawals, enabling swift release and pre-deprivation injunctions when the government fails to respond.