California Case Summaries

Marquez v. Ortiz — Magistrate judge recommends denying summary judgment and qualified immunity where disputes over whether officer intentionally shot prone bystander inmate require trial

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Jonathan Marquez v. O. Ortiz
Court
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Judge
Magistrate judge (name not printed in the order)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
1:23-cv-01782
Status
Unreported
Topics
excessive force, qualified immunity, summary judgment, Eighth Amendment, prison litigation, civil rights

Background

Plaintiff Jonathan Marquez, proceeding pro se and in forma pauperis, sued correctional officer O. Ortiz under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging an Eighth Amendment excessive-force claim arising from a July 8, 2021 incident at Kern Valley State Prison. The operative First Amended Complaint alleged that during a prison-yard fight involving other inmates, Marquez complied with a command to lie prone on the ground and was not a combatant, yet Ortiz fired a 40mm less-lethal launcher six times in his direction, striking him three times, including in the upper body and lip.

On May 30, 2025, the presiding District Judge adopted in part earlier screening findings and allowed the case to proceed solely on the excessive-force claim against Ortiz, dismissing all other claims and defendants. Ortiz moved for summary judgment on August 17, 2026, arguing that his use of non-lethal force was a good-faith effort to stop an ongoing fight and that any strike of an uninvolved inmate was inadvertent, and alternatively asserting qualified immunity. Marquez opposed, pointing to his not-guilty disciplinary finding, an inmate witness statement, and alleged inconsistencies in Ortiz's incident reports and declarations regarding the number of shots and his targeting.

The Court’s Holding

The magistrate judge found genuine disputes of material fact on nearly every excessive-force factor: the need for force, the relationship between need and amount of force, the threat reasonably perceived, and efforts to temper the response. Ortiz's own declaration stated he discharged rounds at Marquez's thighs, while elsewhere asserting he did not aim at prone inmates — an internal inconsistency, combined with conflicting evidence about whether Marquez was a combatant or bystander, that precluded summary judgment.

The court also rejected Ortiz's qualified-immunity defense at this stage. Because a factfinder could conclude Ortiz intentionally shot a passive, uninvolved inmate lying prone near a fight — conduct the court concluded would violate clearly established Eighth Amendment law — and because objective reasonableness turns on those disputed facts, the court recommended denying summary judgment in full.

Key Takeaways

  • Excessive-force claims turn on disputed facts about intent, threat, and proportionality, and summary judgment is to be granted sparingly in this area.
  • An officer's inconsistent accounts of whether projectiles were aimed at or merely struck a bystander can themselves create a triable issue precluding summary judgment.
  • Qualified immunity cannot resolve a case where the officer's reasonableness depends on contested facts about whether the plaintiff was a participant or a passive bystander.
  • Findings and recommendations from a magistrate judge are proposals subject to objections within fourteen days and review by the assigned District Judge, not final judgments.

Why It Matters

This recommendation illustrates how factual disputes about an inmate's role in a disturbance and an officer's targeting intent defeat both merits and qualified-immunity defenses at summary judgment, even where less-lethal force was used during a genuine prison fight.

The document is a proposed ruling only: it recommends denial of Ortiz's motion and leaves final adjudication to the District Judge after any objections, so no final judgment or mandate issues from this writing.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top