California Case Summaries

TruConnect Communications, Inc. v. Maximus Inc. et al. — Software Contractors for State Utility Program Owe No Tort Duty of Care to Participating Service Provider for Purely Economic Losses

Reported / Citable

Case
TruConnect Communications, Inc. v. Maximus Inc. et al.
Court
1st District Court of Appeal
Judge
Humes (Jerry Brown, 2012); Banke (Arnold Schwarzenegger, 2009); Smiley (Gavin Newsom, 2025)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
A172474
Status
Reported / Citable
Topics
economic loss rule, duty of care, Biakanja factors, government contractors, public utilities commission, quantum meruit, restitution, invalidating mistake

Background

Plaintiff TruConnect Communications, Inc., a major wireless provider participating in California's government-subsidized LifeLine program overseen by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), derives over 90 percent of its revenue from LifeLine subscribers. In 2018, the CPUC contracted with Maximus Inc., which subcontracted with Solix Inc., to build and implement a replacement software platform to administer enrollments and track reimbursements.

Following the platform launch in April 2019, widespread software defects allegedly caused hundreds of thousands of eligible applicants and renewing subscribers to be erroneously denied, causing TruConnect tens of millions of dollars in lost revenues and over $3 million in staff time spent attempting to fix the system. The CPUC approved some initial claims for lost revenues and costs, but in September 2020 adopted Resolution T-17707 rejecting reimbursement for lost-opportunity costs. TruConnect then sued Maximus and Solix for negligence, negligent interference with prospective economic relations, quantum meruit, unjust enrichment, and unfair business practices.

The San Francisco Superior Court sustained Maximus's demurrer without leave to amend, concluding that defendants owed TruConnect no legal duty of care to protect against purely economic losses and that TruConnect failed to state valid claims for restitution or quantum meruit. The court overruled Solix's demurrer on the ground that the CPUC was not a necessary and indispensable party, but dismissed the complaint in its entirety as to both defendants because it failed to state a cause of action. TruConnect appealed to the First District Court of Appeal.

The Court’s Holding

The First District Court of Appeal affirmed the judgment of dismissal. Applying the multi-factor balancing test under Biakanja v. Irving, the court held that Maximus and Solix owed no common-law tort duty of care to protect TruConnect from purely economic losses. Although harm was foreseeable and closely linked to defendants' performance, the underlying contract between the CPUC and Maximus was intended to benefit low-income consumers and the commission's statutory oversight rather than to confer a direct benefit on TruConnect or guarantee its revenues.

The court emphasized that TruConnect was a sophisticated commercial entity capable of protecting itself through private ordering, contracting, or insurance, and that imposing tort liability would expose government contractors to potential liability grossly disproportionate to fault, driving up public contracting costs and discouraging prospective vendors. Because the negligence claim failed for lack of duty, TruConnect's derivative claims for negligent interference and unfair business practices under Business and Professions Code section 17200 necessarily failed.

Addressing the restitution and quantum meruit theories, the court rejected TruConnect's argument based on sections 5 and 7 of the Restatement Third of Restitution and Unjust Enrichment. The court determined that TruConnect's subjective belief that the CPUC might reimburse it for salvage efforts did not constitute an objective mistake of fact or law sufficient to establish an invalidating mistake under section 5, and that section 7 did not fit because there was no alleged mistake over the scope of the parties' respective duties. TruConnect consciously assumed the business risk of assisting without an enforceable agreement.

Key Takeaways

  • Under California's economic loss rule, contractors administering public benefit programs generally owe no tort duty of care to commercial program participants for purely economic damages absent a special relationship intended to benefit those specific participants.
  • Foreseeability of commercial injury alone is insufficient under the Biakanja framework to create tort liability for pure financial harm in the absence of privity.
  • A commercial actor cannot compel restitution from a third-party contractor under a theory of 'invalidating mistake' where it voluntarily performs corrective work to protect its own business interests without an express payment agreement.

Why It Matters

The ruling reinforces California's robust adherence to the economic loss rule in the government contracting and public utility administration spheres, safeguarding public vendors from open-ended tort exposure to commercial program intermediaries.

It also delineates clear boundaries between contractual risk allocation and tort duties, cautioning commercial participants in state programs that lost business opportunities cannot be recouped through negligence claims against fellow government contractors.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top