California Case Summaries

Gallegos Meraz v. Blanche — Ninth Circuit Denies Petition for Review Where Single Unfulfilled Threat to Separated Spouse Did Not Compel Finding of Persecution

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Gallegos Meraz v. Blanche
Court
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
Judge
Hawkins (William J. Clinton, 1994); Wardlaw (Bill Clinton, 1998); Hurwitz (Barack Obama, 2012)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
25-5617
Status
Unreported
Topics
Immigration, Asylum, Withholding of Removal, Convention Against Torture, Substantial Evidence Standard

Background

Karen Susana Gallegos Meraz and her minor child, both natives and citizens of Honduras, petitioned for review of a Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) decision dismissing their appeal from an immigration judge's denial of applications for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT).

The petition was premised on events spanning a six-month period in Honduras during which Gallegos Meraz's husband received a single verbal threat and believed he had been followed once. Gallegos Meraz conceded that she was never personally threatened and that her husband suffered no physical harm. Furthermore, the couple subsequently separated, and her husband had relocated to another country.

The Court’s Holding

The Ninth Circuit denied the petition for review under 8 U.S.C. § 1252, reviewing the agency's factual findings under the deferential substantial evidence standard under which agency conclusions must be upheld unless the record compels a contrary result. The panel held that the record fully supported the agency's determination that Gallegos Meraz failed to demonstrate past persecution or a well-founded fear of future persecution, as unfulfilled threats without physical harm directed at a now-separated spouse outside the country did not compel a finding of persecution.

Because petitioners failed to meet the lower burden of proof required for asylum, the panel concluded they necessarily failed to satisfy the more stringent standard for withholding of removal. Additionally, the panel affirmed the denial of CAT relief, finding that generalized evidence of violence and crime in Honduras did not establish that Gallegos Meraz was more likely than not to face a particularized risk of torture upon return.

Key Takeaways

  • An unfulfilled threat directed once at an applicant's family member, without physical harm or personal threats toward the applicant, does not compel an agency finding of persecution under the substantial evidence standard.
  • An applicant who fails to satisfy the burden of proof required for asylum necessarily cannot satisfy the more demanding burden required for statutory withholding of removal.
  • Eligibility for CAT relief requires showing an individualized likelihood of torture rather than submitting generalized evidence of crime or violence in the country of removal.
  • The Ninth Circuit denied as moot the petitioners' motion to stay removal while maintaining the temporary stay in place until issuance of the mandate.

Why It Matters

This decision highlights the demanding burden facing immigration petitioners challenging negative BIA determinations on petition for review under the substantial evidence standard. Where threats remain isolated, unexecuted, and aimed indirectly at family members who have since relocated, the Ninth Circuit will not disturb immigration court findings that such incidents fall short of persecution.

The ruling also reaffirms established circuit precedent regarding CAT claims, confirming that generalized country condition reports depicting broad criminal violence remain insufficient to mandate protection absent concrete evidence of an individualized risk of torture.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top