California Case Summaries

Gonzalez-Alfaro v. Blanche — Ninth Circuit Denies Petition Reviewing BIA Discretionary Remand Denial and Hardship Finding for Cancellation of Removal

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Gonzalez-Alfaro v. Blanche
Court
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
Judge
Forrest (Donald Trump, 2019); Tung; Stanley Allen Bastian
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
24-1896
Status
Unreported
Topics
immigration, cancellation of removal, motion to remand, exceptional hardship, Board of Immigration Appeals, discretionary judgment

Background

Petitioner Fernando Gonzalez-Alfaro, a native and citizen of Mexico, petitioned for review of a Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) decision that dismissed his appeal from an Immigration Judge's removal order and denied his motion to remand. Gonzalez-Alfaro sought cancellation of removal and moved to remand his proceedings to present new evidence regarding his family circumstances.

The BIA denied the motion to remand in the exercise of discretion because Gonzalez-Alfaro failed to establish that the newly submitted evidence would likely change the outcome of his case. It also upheld the denial of cancellation of removal based on a lack of qualifying hardship to his United States citizen children.

The Court’s Holding

The Ninth Circuit denied the petition for review. Addressing the motion to remand, the court observed that the BIA may deny remand on three independent grounds, including a discretionary determination that relief is not warranted. Because the BIA exercised its purely discretionary judgment that the evidence would not likely alter the result, the court lacked jurisdiction under 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(2)(B)(i) to reexamine that determination.

Exercising jurisdiction under 8 U.S.C. § 1252 to review the hardship determination, the court held that substantial evidence supported the agency's conclusion that Gonzalez-Alfaro failed to demonstrate exceptional hardship under Wilkinson v. Garland. The court noted that his children would continue receiving support from their mother and extended family, could reside in his house or with their mother, and that any hardship would not be substantially beyond the expected impact of a close relative's removal.

Key Takeaways

  • A motion to remand before the BIA is governed by the same standards as a motion to reopen and may be denied based on failure to show a prima facie case, failure to offer previously unavailable material evidence, or discretionary judgment.
  • The Ninth Circuit lacks jurisdiction under 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(2)(B)(i) to review the BIA's purely discretionary determination that supplemental evidence would not likely change the outcome on a motion to remand.
  • An agency's evaluation of exceptional and extremely unusual hardship for cancellation of removal requires showing hardship out of the ordinary and exceedingly uncommon, which remains subject to substantial evidence review.

Why It Matters

The decision reaffirms the strict jurisdictional limitations curtailing appellate review of the BIA's discretionary denial of motions to remand or reopen, while applying the Supreme Court's Wilkinson framework to review the mixed question of whether established facts satisfy the statutory hardship standard for cancellation of removal.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top