Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Linwood Hosea Gordon, a federal inmate housed at the Federal Correctional Institution in Taft, initiated a pro se habeas corpus proceeding under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 challenging a January 27, 2026 prison disciplinary finding. Gordon sought an order vacating the finding, restoring 41 days of forfeited good conduct time credit, and correcting his projected release date. He alleged due process violations at his disciplinary hearing, asserting that he was denied opportunities to present evidence and call witnesses, and that the hearing officer improperly found him guilty of possessing a hazardous tool despite an incident report citing him only for unauthorized telephone use.
Judicial notice of Gordon's underlying criminal record established that he was convicted of abusive sexual contact under 18 U.S.C. § 2244(b), sentenced to 24 months in prison followed by 60 months of supervised release, and released from Bureau of Prisons custody to begin supervised release on April 24, 2026. Following an August 2026 revocation petition, the district court found Gordon violated release conditions, sentenced him to time served, and stayed release pending placement at a residential re-entry center. Meanwhile, the respondent warden moved to dismiss the § 2241 petition, arguing that Gordon's initial April 2026 release rendered the action moot.
The Court’s Holding
U.S. Magistrate Judge Chi Soo Kim recommended denying the respondent's motion to dismiss and directing the warden to file an answer within thirty days of an order adopting the recommendation. The magistrate judge reasoned that under Ninth Circuit precedent, a habeas petition challenging prison disciplinary sanctions is not mooted by release from physical custody when the petitioner remains subject to an active term of supervised release, because a sentencing court retains statutory discretion to modify or reduce the length of supervision in light of erroneous confinement.
The court noted that the respondent failed to address Gordon's ongoing 60-month supervised release term, omitted any discussion of continuing collateral consequences, and did not address the merits of the procedural due process claims. Furthermore, Gordon's subsequent return to federal custody following supervision revocation confirmed that a live Article III controversy persisted. Concurrently, the magistrate judge ordered the civil action reassigned to District Judge Daniel J. Calabretta, the presiding judge in Gordon's underlying criminal prosecution.
Key Takeaways
- Release from Bureau of Prisons custody does not moot a 28 U.S.C. § 2241 habeas petition challenging disciplinary sanctions when the petitioner remains subject to an unexpired term of supervised release.
- Because a sentencing court retains statutory discretion to modify or terminate supervised release, redressable collateral consequences persist after physical incarceration ends.
- A petitioner's subsequent return to federal custody following supervision revocation provides an independent basis establishing an active Article III case or controversy.
- Under Rule 4, a motion to dismiss a habeas petition on mootness grounds must directly address a petitioner's active supervision status and asserted collateral injuries.
Why It Matters
This decision illustrates the application of the collateral-consequences doctrine within the Ninth Circuit, confirming that the expiration of a primary term of imprisonment does not extinguish federal habeas jurisdiction where unexpired supervised release terms remain subject to potential judicial reduction.
By recommending that the government be required to answer the petition notwithstanding post-filing custodial shifts, the magistrate judge ensures that prison disciplinary due process claims do not evade judicial review when intertwined with ongoing federal supervision.