California Case Summaries

In re D.B. — Order Denying Mother’s Section 388 Modification Petition Affirmed for Failure to Show Changed Circumstances

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
In re D.B.
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Ashworth; Adams (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Hanasono
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
B353182
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
juvenile dependency, section 388 modification petition, family reunification services, changed circumstances, child best interests, parental substance abuse

Background

D.B. was detained shortly after his premature birth in October 2022 after his mother admitted using methamphetamine during pregnancy and tested positive for illicit drugs. The juvenile court sustained a dependency petition based on substance abuse, removed D.B. from parental custody, and ordered reunification services including drug treatment, random drug testing, and individual counseling. D.B., who was later diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder and language impairments, was placed with foster mother Ms. W., who continuously provided for his specialized therapeutic and developmental needs.

Due to minimal compliance and missed drug tests, the juvenile court terminated reunification services in November 2023. In December 2025, mother filed a Welfare and Institutions Code section 388 petition seeking reinstated reunification services, citing her January 2025 completion of an outpatient drug program. DCFS opposed the petition because mother had not provided drug test results since services were terminated and refused on-demand testing. Following a January 28, 2026 hearing, the juvenile court denied the petition and terminated parental rights, prompting mother's appeal.

The Court’s Holding

The Second District Court of Appeal affirmed the juvenile court's order denying mother's section 388 petition, finding no abuse of discretion. The appellate court held that substantial evidence supported the finding of changing, rather than changed, circumstances. Although mother completed an outpatient program in January 2025, she presented no evidence of drug testing during the eleven months prior to filing her petition, showed no proof of aftercare or 12-step participation, and declined DCFS testing requests, justifying an adverse inference regarding her continued sobriety.

The court further held that resuming reunification services was contrary to D.B.'s best interests. Once reunification services are terminated, the statutory focus shifts from parental rehabilitation to the child's compelling need for permanency and stability. Given that three-year-old D.B. had never lived with mother, required intensive care for nonverbal autism, and possessed a primary bond with his prospective adoptive caregiver Ms. W., the juvenile court reasonably concluded that delaying permanency to allow another reunification attempt would undermine his stability.

Key Takeaways

  • A parent seeking to modify dependency orders under section 388 after services have ended must demonstrate genuinely changed, not merely changing, circumstances.
  • Completion of a substance abuse program without contemporaneous proof of ongoing sobriety or drug testing is insufficient to establish changed circumstances when substance abuse caused the dependency.
  • Once reunification services are terminated, the statutory priority shifts from parental rehabilitation to the child's compelling need for permanency and stability.
  • An unexcused failure or refusal to submit to requested drug testing may properly be treated as the equivalent of a positive drug test in dependency proceedings.

Why It Matters

The decision reinforces the strict evidentiary threshold parents face under Welfare and Institutions Code section 388 on the eve of permanency planning, confirming that past completion of treatment milestones does not substitute for contemporaneous proof of maintained sobriety. It also affirms that a child's specialized medical and developmental vulnerabilities strongly favor preserving an established, secure caregiving placement over speculative parental rehabilitation.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top