Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Fernando Avila Perez was convicted in 2004 of attempted premeditated murder and shooting into an occupied vehicle. On both counts, the jury found true the allegation that Perez personally discharged a firearm causing great bodily injury under Penal Code section 12022.53, subdivision (d). After a prior-strike finding, he received 14 years to life consecutive to a 25-years-to-life firearm enhancement.
In 2024 Perez asked the trial court to recall his sentence and resentence him under Penal Code section 1172.1, citing statutory changes and his postconviction conduct, including roughly 20 years served, payment of restitution, program completion, and renunciation of gang ties. The court appointed counsel, ordered the release of subpoenaed records to the defense, received briefing and supporting letters, and held a hearing.
The court expressly acknowledged Perez's progress in custody but declined his invitation to recall the sentence, noting that his achievements could be considered at parole hearings. Appointed counsel filed an opening brief presenting no issues beyond appealability, and Perez filed a supplemental brief seeking recall on new grounds involving crime-scene photographs and a forensic report.
The Court’s Holding
The Court of Appeal treated the order as appealable under People v. Olea because the trial court did more than ignore a defendant-initiated request: it appointed counsel, ordered the release of subpoenaed records to the defense, held a hearing, considered statutory postconviction factors, and effectively evaluated and denied the petition on the merits, affecting Perez's substantial rights.
Perez's supplemental argument that trial testimony about two 9-millimeter casings was false was not arguable on appeal. He had not raised that claim in the trial court, so it was forfeited; it depended on materials outside the appellate record; and documents presented for the first time on appeal could not show that the trial court abused its discretion when it ruled.
Because Perez raised no arguable appellate issue, the court affirmed the order declining recall and resentencing.
Key Takeaways
- A defendant-initiated section 1172.1 request ordinarily need not be answered, but a court that appoints counsel, orders release of subpoenaed records to the defense, holds a hearing, and denies the request on the merits creates an appealable postjudgment order under the reasoning of People v. Olea.
- A decision not to recall and resentence is reviewed for abuse of discretion when the trial court has effectively evaluated the request on the merits.
- Claims of constitutional error or evidence undermining a conviction may be relevant under section 1172.1, subdivision (a)(5), but a defendant must present them to the trial court and cannot obtain review based on materials outside the record supplied for the first time on appeal.
- The Court of Appeal applies the Delgadillo procedure when appointed counsel raises no issues, but affirmance remains appropriate when the defendant's supplemental brief presents no arguable appellate issue.
Why It Matters
The decision reinforces the Sixth District's approach distinguishing a trial court's nonresponse to a section 1172.1 request from a merits-based denial that affects substantial rights and is therefore appealable.
It also illustrates the practical limits of using a resentencing appeal to litigate alleged trial error: forfeiture, the record on appeal, and review of the trial court's decision at the time it was made all independently bar newly presented impeachment materials.