Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
An amended wardship petition alleged that F.V., then two months shy of 18, committed firearm possession, murder, and two counts of attempted premeditated murder arising from a February 2, 2023 shooting at Montclair Plaza that killed 15-year-old Omar E. The prosecution sought transfer to adult criminal court under Welfare and Institutions Code section 707 and California Rules of Court, rule 5.770.
At transfer hearings held in January and February 2026, the juvenile court heard gang-expert testimony, investigating officers, defense psychologist Dr. Marina Bassili, Probation Officer Citlaly Juarez-Rodriguez, ARISE program officer Rebecca Lonnstrom, and victim-impact testimony. Dr. Bassili opined F.V. was amenable to juvenile treatment, while both probation officers found him unsuitable for the ARISE program and unlikely to rehabilitate within remaining juvenile jurisdiction.
The juvenile court granted transfer, finding by clear and convincing evidence that each of the five statutory criteria favored transfer and that F.V. was not amenable to rehabilitation. F.V. appealed, arguing the court failed to analyze the criteria through the lens of amenability and that the non-amenability finding lacked substantial evidence.
The Court’s Holding
The Court of Appeal held that amenability to rehabilitation is the central and dispositive question under amended section 707, and that participation in available programming does not itself establish willingness to be restored to constructive society. The court's 37-page statement of decision articulated its evaluative process and weighed the evidence against the applicable standards.
Substantial evidence supported the finding that insufficient time remained to rehabilitate F.V.: roughly four years remained before age 25, both probation officers testified that was inadequate, and F.V. continued gang activity, code reds, and rule violations during three years of detention. The court distinguished In re O.F., where all testimony supported sufficient rehabilitation time and the youth showed growth potential absent here.
The appellate court also found substantial evidence supporting each remaining criterion—criminal sophistication, prior delinquency, prior rehabilitation efforts, and offense gravity—and concluded the juvenile court properly made the ultimate clear-and-convincing finding of non-amenability. The transfer order was affirmed.
Key Takeaways
- Under amended section 707, juvenile courts must analyze all five transfer criteria through the lens of amenability to rehabilitation, which remains the central and dispositive question.
- Evidence of program participation and academic achievement does not compel a finding of amenability when weighed against continued gang involvement, violence, and resistance to treatment.
- Expert and probation testimony about available programs, their duration, and whether rehabilitation can occur before jurisdiction expires is critical to the second statutory criterion.
- Substantial evidence review draws all reasonable inferences in support of the juvenile court's findings, and the ultimate non-amenability finding is reviewed under that standard.
- In re O.F. is distinguishable where record evidence shows less remaining jurisdiction time, contrary probation testimony, and repeated misconduct during detention.
Why It Matters
This unpublished opinion applies the renewed statutory focus on rehabilitation in section 707 transfer proceedings while affirming that documented, continued resistance to rehabilitation can support adult transfer even where a youth participates extensively in programming and academic work.
The decision underscores that amenability analysis is fact-intensive and record-specific: positive adjustment evidence must be weighed against ongoing gang entrenchment, violence, and the practical limits of remaining juvenile jurisdiction.