Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
In 2009, a jury convicted Charles Dejun Gant of possession of cocaine base for sale and being a felon in possession of a firearm. Gant admitted a gang enhancement and a prior drug conviction enhancement under former Health and Safety Code section 11370.2. In 2010, the trial court sentenced him to an aggregate prison term of eight years and eight months, including three years on count 1, eight months on count 2, two years for the gang enhancement, and three years for the prior drug conviction enhancement.
In September 2024, Gant filed a petition for resentencing under Penal Code section 1172.7, which invalidated his prior drug conviction enhancement. At resentencing, the trial court struck the drug enhancement but declined to reconsider his gang enhancement under Assembly Bill 333, reimposed an aggregate term of five years and eight months with three years on count 1, and calculated custody credits including postsentence conduct credits. Gant appealed.
The Court’s Holding
The California Court of Appeal for the Second Appellate District reversed the resentencing judgment. The court held that a sentence recall under Penal Code section 1172.7 requires full resentencing, reopening all sentencing choices and rendering the judgment nonfinal under In re Estrada. Consequently, Gant is entitled to the retroactive benefit of Assembly Bill 333's heightened proof requirements for gang enhancements under Penal Code section 186.22, requiring remand for the trial court to assess the enhancement or permit retrial.
The court also held that on remand, the trial court must resolve ambiguity regarding count 1 and recalculate custody credits. Because the sentencing triad for Gant's offense changed from three, four, or five years to two, three, or four years in 2015, the trial court must clarify whether it intended to impose the current low term of two years or the middle term of three years. Additionally, while the trial court must recalculate actual presentence and postsentence custody days, it lacked authority under People v. Buckhalter to calculate postsentence conduct credits, which are reserved exclusively to prison authorities.
Key Takeaways
- A sentence recall under Penal Code section 1172.7 reopens all sentencing choices and renders the judgment nonfinal for purposes of retroactive ameliorative legislation under In re Estrada.
- Defendants undergoing section 1172.7 resentencing are entitled to the retroactive application of Assembly Bill 333, requiring gang enhancements under Penal Code section 186.22 to satisfy amended proof requirements.
- Trial courts conducting resentencing must apply current sentencing triads and clearly state whether they intend to impose the current low, middle, or upper term.
- Resentencing courts must calculate actual presentence and postsentence custody days but cannot award postsentence conduct credits, which remain within the exclusive authority of the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
Why It Matters
This decision clarifies that section 1172.7 resentencing constitutes a plenary proceeding that reopens finality, ensuring that defendants benefit from intervening ameliorative criminal statutes such as Assembly Bill 333. The ruling also underscores essential procedural boundaries on resentencing, directing trial courts to apply amended statutory triads accurately and strictly respect the jurisdictional divide between judicial calculations of actual custody time and administrative awards of prison conduct credits.